Listen to 80 lakh owners

Rehman Sobhan urges govt about Grameen Bank at micro-credit roundtable
The government should heed the calls of 80 lakh Grameen Bank shareholders and let a democratic process determine how the organisation will be run, eminent economist Rehman Sobhan said yesterday.
“If you respect democracy, the prime ownership rests with the principal shareholders of the organisation. This is the simple proposition you have to keep in your mind — what do 80 lakh owners want in the organisation,” he said.
“Address their needs. Are they complaining about how the organisation is being run? Let the democratic process decide how the activities of the organisation should be conducted.”
“All organisations respond to democratic mandate through the instrument of ownership and accountability, with the principal accountability comes through the process of who own it. The whole thing has to be done through the democratisation of ownership,” Sobhan said.
He made the remarks at a roundtable on “Microcredit and Poverty Alleviation” organised by leading Bangla daily Prothom Alo at its office in the capital.
The comments came days after the government removed Prof Muhammad Yunus from Grameen Bank — a move considered by many as a plot to take control of the country’s most prestigious organisation.
The economist said there are many misgivings about the concept of microcredit, and the notion that microcredit is supposed to alleviate poverty is pointless.
He mentioned the government spends 30 to 40 percent of its annual development budget for poverty alleviation and said, “You can easily measure the government’s investment in the area in the last 20 to 30 years and the reduction in poverty. Then you will reach a conclusion for who is responsible for what.”
“In this circumstance, we are now caught in a totally ridiculous discussion. What you have to do is to put it into perspective.”
Sobhan said microcredit creates opportunity for people to get out of extreme poverty.
“The lesson should be what would be our direction from here. This is a 30-year-old sector and a lot of significant changes have taken place.”
Sobhan said the great contribution of Grameen Bank is that it recognises the ownership of its shareholders.
“The government contributed Tk 1.8 crore out of Tk 53 crore of capitalisation of an organisation, and now claims to be the supreme owner of the organisation,” he said.
Former Bangladesh Bank governor Salehuddin Ahmed said there has been a microcredit boom in Bangladesh, as the poor did not have any access to finance.
“Many programmes and projects were taken to help the poor in the past, but nothing worked.”
“The sector is very disciplined and everyone should think what would have happened if microcredit had not existed. Its impact can only be felt but can not be measured easily by index,” he said.
SR Osmani, professor of economics at the University of Ulster, said the ongoing discussion on microcredit in the media is misleading.
“They talk about high interest rates. But they never consider that commercial banks do not want to lend money to the poor and will not be able to do so even if they want to.”
“It will be pointless to compare interest rates between microfinance institutions and commercial banks.”
Osmani countered the claim that microcredit borrowers have been continuing loans for years and said, “The same happens in the formal sector, where entrepreneurs continue bank loans as long as they are alive. Then, why is this double standard?”
He came down hard on the critics of the concept of microcredit, who say it could not eradicate poverty despite being in practice for three decades in Bangladesh.
“The politicians have been spending thousands of crores of taka for years in the name of poverty alleviation. But we do not see any reduction in the poverty level.”
Referring to studies between 1988 and 2008, Osmani said, “Those who participated in microcredit programmes were better off than those who were not involved in any microfinance institutions.”
MM Akash, professor of economics at Dhaka University, said the spectrum of interest rates in the sector creates suspicion. If one microfinance institution, such as Grameen, charges 10 percent flat rate, others charge 15 to 20 percent.
“Microcredit Regulatory Authority needs to regulate this.”
The economist said differential treatment of microfinance institutions has made a mess in the sector that needs to be cleared.
Hossain Zillur Rahman, former adviser to a caretaker government, said Grameen Bank has been unfairly put in the dock on various grounds.
“We see a major danger in this, as many of our microcredit-related achievements such as girls’ enrolment in schools will be questioned,” he said.
Binayak Sen, research director of Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies, said the government spends Tk 27,000 crore for poverty alleviation every year.
“This has been going on for years. But we do not see any dramatic change in poverty alleviation,” he said.
Prothom Alo Editor Matiur Rahman also spoke at the roundtable.

 

Courtesy of The Daily Star

Related News

Depression, cold wave anticipated in late December

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A low to moderate cold wave – coupled with a depression – could grip the country at the end of December. As a result, mercury may dip as low as 6 Degrees Celsius in some regions of the country, Bangladesh Meteorological Department forecasted on Thursday. Bangladesh could see less rainfall than ... Read more

Car hits woman and drags her through DU campus, killing her

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The woman who was hit by a private car and dragged for several hundred yards on Dhaka University (DU) campus this afternoon died at Dhaka Medical College Hospital. She passed away around 4:30pm at DMCH, Masud Mia, an assistant sub-inspector of DMCH Police Outpost. The deceased was identified as Rubina Akther, ... Read more

International Travel & Tourism Expo from December 1

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com The first-ever Bangladesh International Travel and Tourism Expo BITTE, will open on December 1 in Dhaka for three days to promote of the country’s tourism industry and exposure to international visitors. The organiser of the expo, the Association of Travel Agents of Bangladesh (ATAB), organised a press conference in this regard ... Read more

90 lakh people will get Covid vaccine from December 1-7

News Desk : dhakamirror.com From December 1-7, the government will conduct a nationwide Covid vaccination program, with the goal of giving shots (including boosters) to 90 lakh individuals. Shamsul Hoque, member secretary of the vaccine deployment committee of Directorate General of Health Serv ices (DGHS), said this at a press briefing today. The campaign, which ... Read more

Pori Moni tells court she was “sexually harassed” at Uttara Boat Club

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Today, Pori Moni told a Dhaka tribunal about being sexually harassed by Dhaka’s Uttara Boat Club Limited’s former president Nasir U Mahmud, his assistant Tuhin Siddiqui Omi, and others in June of last year. Pori Moni said this while giving her depositions against Nasir, Omi and their associate Shah Shahidul Alam ... Read more

87.44% student pass SSC, equivalent examinations

2,69,602 get GPA 5 News Desk : dhakamirror.com The results of this year’s Secondary School Certificate and its equivalent examinations were published on Monday. The combined pass rate of SSC examination of all the education boards across Bangladesh and equivalent examinations in 2022 is 87.44 per cent. The rate was 93.58 per cent in 2021. ... Read more

Two New ticket counters in Kolkata for India-Bangladesh travelers

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Due to the high volume of people traveling between India and Bangladesh, the Indian Railways have erected two more ticket booths at Kolkata station. The demand for train tickets has increased dramatically since the drop of Covid-19 infections, reports The Daily Star quoted an Indian railway official as saying . The ... Read more

Two new divisions are planned

They’ll include Faridpur and Cumilla regions. News Desk : dhakamirror.com Padma and Meghna will be two new divisions created by the government, each containing districts from the existing Faridpur and Cumilla areas. A Cabinet Division official has stated that the topic will be discussed at this Sunday’s meeting of the National Implementation Committee for Administrative ... Read more

Argentine fan dies in Cumilla during the match between Argentina and Saudi Arabia

News Desk : dhakamirror.com On Tuesday evening in Burichong upazila, Cumilla, an argentine fan died after experiencing chest pains while watching the FIFA World Cup match between Argentina and Saudi Arabia. The dead, 50-year-old Kawsar Javed alias Kakon, son of the late Abdul Khaleque of the Shikarpur village in the Shikarpur upazila, collapsed with chest ... Read more

World Children’s Day: Unicef report exposes vast inequalities

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Today, as it does every year, the United Nations Children’s Fund (Unicef) is celebrating World Children’s Day in an effort to give children a voice in advocating for a better tomorrow and a more equitable and inclusive world. This year, the day will focus on the theme of “Inclusion, For Every ... Read more

NRSC turned down proposal to ban bikes on highways

Plan to reduce road accidents by 25% in 2 years is approved News Desk : dhakamirror.com In order to reduce traffic fatalities by a quarter by 2024 and by half by 2030, the National Road Safety Council (NRSC) approved the National Road Safety Strategic Action Plan (2020-24). At its 29th meeting held yesterday in the ... Read more

Ban on bikes on highways, action plan to be discussed at NRSC meeting

News Desk : dhakamirror.com After a gap of 21 months, the National Road Safety Council (NRSC), the highest government body dealing with road safety issues, will convene tomorrow. The National Road Safety Strategic Action Plan-2021-2024, the prohibition of motorcycles on busy highways, and the refusal to register vehicles that have been deemed abandoned are the ... Read more

Joypurhat train accident claims life of KUET student

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Early on Friday, a student from Khulna University of Engineering and Technology was killed when he was pinned between the train’s wheels at the Joypurhat Railway Station in the city’s district. He was a 23-year-old third-year student in the Leather Engineering Department at the KUET and the son of Shahriar Rais ... Read more

Fishermen are allowed to fish again after 22-day ban

A 22-day fishing ban on Hilsa, imposed to protect the fish during its peak breeding season has ended News Desk : dhakamirror.com The government lifted a 22-day ban on catching, selling, and transporting Hilsa on Friday. This meant that Hilsa could be caught, sold, and moved again on Saturday. When different kinds of fish caught ... Read more

30% of Bangladeshis face food scarcity

World Bank survey on Bangladesh’s Covid effect News Desk : dhakamirror.com A World Bank report finds 30 percent of Bangladeshis are enduring food scarcity despite the country’s economic recovery from pandemic-induced disruptions. The percentage of persons who went to sleep hungry virtually doubled from 7 percent in June last year to 13 percent in May ... Read more

Ctg and Cox’s Bazar airports will be closed for 21 hours

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Due to the adverse weather caused by Cyclone Sitrang, Chattogram and Cox’s Bazar airports will be closed for 21 hours, from 3 p.m. today until 12 p.m. tomorrow. Both Wing Commander Farhad H. Khan, director of Chattogram Airport, and Joydev Kumar Biswas, aerodrome officer at Cox’s Bazar Airport, confirmed this to ... Read more

Concern as vehicle fitness clearance hits a seven-year low

News Desk : dhakamirror.com While vehicle registrations increased significantly in the previous fiscal year, the number of fitness certifications decreased to a seven-year low, creating more concerns about road safety. At least 5.42 lakh registered vehicles have been functioning on the roads without the required fitness approval, owing to insufficient monitoring by authorities. The decision ... Read more

Shafiqul Islam, DMP commissioner to retire Oct 30

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Dhaka Metropolitan Police (DMP) Commissioner Shafiqul Islam is retiring on October 30. A gazette notification in this regard was issued by the Home Ministry’s Public Security Division on Wednesday. Deputy Secretary Dhananjay Kumar Das signed the notification on the orders of the President. The announcement states that retired Commissioner of Police ... Read more

Among 20 most unsustainable cities, Dhaka comes in at number four

News Desk : dhakamirror.com According to a global research released on Wednesday, Dhaka is ranked fourth among the 20 unsustainable megacities in the world. Lagos, Nairobi, Kinshasa, Dhaka, Baghdad, Lahore, Kolkata, and New Delhi are all expected to have rapid population increase of over 50% by 2050, according to the Ecological Threat Report (ETR) 2022. ... Read more

PBI submits final report in Mosarat murder case

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The Police Bureau of Investigation on Wednesday submitted its final report in the case of killing college student Mosarat Jahan Munia giving clean chit to Bashundhara Group managing director Sayem Sobhan Anvir who was named as the prime accused. Dhaka Metropolitan Police deputy commissioner for prosecution Jashim Uddin said that they ... Read more