Friday, March 29, 2024

Witness the weakness

About 60pc cases suffer as witnesses unwilling to testify for intimidation, hassle; govt talks of a protection act
Zafrun Nahar had spent five years trying to have her son’s killers punished. But no witness showed up to testify at the trial.
Frustrated that all her hard work brought nothing, she now sees no point in trying. “I have waited enough…seen enough. But no more do I wait for justice,” says a battle-weary Zafrun, 61.
Her elder son Himel, 25, was shot dead on Salimullah Road in the capital’s Mohammadpur area in February 1997.
In the murder trial, 34 dates had been set for testimony of the prosecution witnesses. But no-one dared to appear in the court in the face of intimidation by the accused and their associates.
The case proceedings have been stayed by the High Court since January 14, 2002.
Fed up that the trial was going nowhere, Zafrun did not move to have the HC order vacated in last eight years.
Meantime, the accused have secured bail and three of the six eyewitnesses left the country failing to withstand intimidation.
The defendants began bullying the witnesses even before the case went to the court.
“They gathered in front of my house every night, shouting abuse,” said an eyewitness to Himel murder.
One afternoon, another witness was picked up from his office and coerced into giving a statement saying he did not see anything.
“I don’t blame the witnesses. Even I would fear for my life while returning home from the court,” Zafrun said.
“I won’t carry it anymore and won’t go to court anymore,” she added.
Currently, Zafrun is sick and suffering from various diseases. It would not be possible for her to pursue the case even if she wanted.
Lawyers say numerous are the instances where cases could not be resolved even in 20 years due to absence of witnesses. And this is one of the reasons why the courts have to grapple with a huge backlog of cases.
A ballpark estimate is that at least 60% cases in every court suffer for witnesses unwilling to testify, say some public prosecutors at Dhaka judge’s court.
According to a parliamentary sub-committee report, over 15 lakh cases were pending in subordinate courts till January.
Cases relating to women and children repression can be taken as an example. Though the cases are supposed to be settled in 180 days since their initiation, 1,426 cases including 682 in Dhaka are stuck in different courts.
“In more than half the cases, witnesses are not available. Sometimes victims are implicated in false cases so they cannot pursue the case,” said Dr Bilkis Begum, coordinator of Dhaka medical College’s One Stop Crisis Centre.
Law Minister Shafique Ahmed said, “We want to formulate a law to ensure witness protection, and have already asked the ministry to examine everything relevant.”
The problem is so acute that the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in a ruling observed that witnesses do not want to appear before court for fear of reprisals.
In this context, it said, a court can pass verdict on single evidence, provided the proof is convincing.
How many cases are hung for intimidation of witnesses cannot be known, as neither the complainants nor the witnesses file complaints with court or general diaries (GD) with police station.
“It’s no use filing a GD. The accused keep terrorising the witnesses, as police do nothing,” said Shahid Khan who has recently filed a GD with Madaripur Police Station after receiving death threats from those accused of killing his younger brother.
Sometimes it gets beyond intimidation and costs a witness his life.
On May 18, Jubo League activist Rahim was killed in Mirpur while on his way home.
Belayet, who was accompanying him and also injured in the attack, said Rahim was killed as he had seen the murder of a local Jubo League leader.
“Now it’s my turn. The killers are after me. They have been threatening me because I’m the second eyewitness to the first murder and main eyewitness to Rahim killing,” he added.
Lawyers said police rarely act on a GD, leaving the complainant exposed to intimidation and constant threat of attack.
Besides, public prosecutors do not want to cite intimidation as a reason for non-appearance of witness as that would lay bare the state’s failure.
Tawhida Khandker, director of Bangladesh National Women Lawyers Association (BNWLA), said, “Over 50 percent of our cases are making no progress, as witnesses don’t want to show up for intimidation and lack of security.”
Stressing the need for a witness protection act, BNWLA Executive Director Salma Ali said the law must seek to ensure safe shelter, various support services and treatment for victims and witnesses, and punishment to those harassing the victim or witness.
It must also provide for use of interpreter and modern technologies like teleconferencing in taking deposition.
She also said the provision for witness protection in the existing law is inadequate.
Besides intimidation, financial constraints contribute to non-appearance of witnesses, lawyers said.

 

Courtesy of The Daily Star

Related News

bKash communications chief Mahfuz Sadique dies at 40

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Mahfuz Sadique, chief communications officer of mobile financial services firm bKash, passed away in Bangladesh capital Dhaka Friday morning. He was 40. Mahfuz died around 9:00am while undergoing treatment at a hospital in the capital, bKash said in a statement. Mahfuz, who began his career as a journalist at New Age, ... Read more

Prices for potatoes increase by 229% from the previous year

Prices for potatoes varied from Tk16 to Tk22 per kg at this time last year. News Desk : dhakamirror.com Despite the presence of both new and old potatoes in the market, potato prices have soared by 229% compared to late December last year. According to the Trading Corporation of Bangladesh (TCB), the selling price for ... Read more

LGED engineer dead, UNO among 3 injured in Panchagarh car crash

News Desk : dhakamirror.com An engineer of the Local Government Engineering Department (LGED) was killed and three other government officials were injured when the vehicle of a UNO hit a roadside tree in Panchagarh Sadar upazila early today. The deceased was identified as Abu Sayed, 33, upazila engineer of LGED from Pirganj upazila of Thakurgaon. ... Read more

UNHCR calls for rescue of Rohingyas stranded in Andaman Sea

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The United Nations (UN) Refugee Agency, UNHCR, has made an urgent appeal to all countries in the region, particularly those in the area surrounding the Andaman Sea, to swiftly deploy their full search and rescue capacities in response to reported vessels in distress with hundreds of Rohingya at risk of perishing. ... Read more

Over 200 RMG workers injured in Comilla while evacuating factory during earthquake

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Over two hundred garment workers in Cumilla’s Chauddagram have been injured while trying to evacuate the factory building of Amir Shirt Garment Limited during today’s earthquake. A 5.5 magnitude earthquake at a depth of 10km jolted Dhaka, and parts of the country at 9:35am today (2 December). The epicentre of the ... Read more

Daughter hacked father to death in Chattogram

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A father was hacked to death by his own daughter during an altercation over a trivial matter at Lohagara upazila in Chattogram on Friday (1 December). The deceased was identified as Abdur Rahman, 50, of Putibila Sarai village under the upazila. Police have detained the daughter, Humaira Begum, 23, soon after ... Read more

HSC results: Dhaka has most GPA-5 achievers, while Barishal has highest pass rate

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Dhaka had the highest number of GPA-5 recipients in the HSC exams, while Barishal Education Board had the highest pass rate among nine educational boards. Education Minister Dipu Moni announced today that the overall pass rate in the nine general boards is 75.90 percent. In terms of pass rates, Barishal ranked ... Read more

PSC postpones 45th BCS written tests

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The Bangladesh Public Service Commission (PSC) has decided to postpone the written tests for the 45th Bangladesh Civil Service examination, which was scheduled to be held on 27 November. The announcement came through a notification signed by Ananda Kumar Biswas, the exam controller of PSC, issued on Friday. PSC held a ... Read more

After stabbing younger sister to death woman ‘kills herself’ in Hazaribagh

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A woman reportedly killed herself after stabbing her younger sister to death in the capital’s Hazaribagh area today. Police said the incident took place in the Kalunagar area at around 12am on Monday (13 November). The deceased have been identified as Jasmine Akhtar, 44, and her younger sister Nasreen Akhtar, 30. ... Read more

Oman stops issuing new visas to citizens of Bangladesh

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The Sultanate of Oman has suspended the issuance of visas across all categories for Bangladeshi nationals, the Royal Oman Police (ROP) said on Tuesday. The decision was effective from Tuesday, reported Oman-based English newspaper the Times of Oman referring to the Royal Oman Police. The report said that the ROP confirmed ... Read more

Dhaka girl Nupur takes over as chairman of Unilever for a day

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Seventeen-year-old Nupur from Dhaka, had the opportunity to take over Unilever’s chairman position for one day on Thursday. There, she symbolically carried out the roles and responsibilities of Zaved Akhtar, the chairman and managing director of Unilever Bangladesh, said a press release. Nupur being an active youth club member, works for ... Read more

Hospitals must follow guidelines, orders HC

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The High Court on Thursday asked the government to take steps to make it compulsory to follow the relevant guidelines for the prevention of performing unnecessary caesarean section surgery at government and private hospitals and clinics. The court has also directed the government to widely circulate the guidelines within six months. ... Read more

Woman delivers birth to five babies at DMCH

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A woman has given birth to five premature babies. The quintuplets were born at the Dhaka Medical College Hospital (DMCH) at 10am on Thursday to Mansura Begum, 22, the wife of CNG driver Md Mamun from Bandardia village in Shibpur upazila of Narsingdi district. One of the newborns, however, died shortly ... Read more

Tk8.44 cr fine imposed to Kazi Farms, 3.44 crore to Suguna Food

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The Bangladesh Competition Commission has fined Kazi Farms Group and Saguna Food and Feeds on charges of market manipulation causing abnormal rise in broiler chicken prices. BCC officials said that the companies must deposit the fine amount to the BCC within 10 working days. If they fail to deposit the fine ... Read more

Heritage volunteers visit national museum

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The heritage volunteers participating in UNESCO World Heritage Volunteers Programme 2023 visited national museum in Dhaka on Sunday. The ten-day workshop programme organised by Nagar Upakhyan-Perceive started on October 1, said a press release. The Heritage volunteers’ team visited national museum which is on the UNESCO World Heritage tentative list on ... Read more

Fare for Bangladesh-India trains to increase from November 10

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Ticket prices of three inter-country trains on Bangladesh-India routes are going to be hiked from November 10. The fares are going to increase due to high exchange rate of US dollar and rising travel tax, according to the Bangladesh Railway officials. The trains are – Maitree Express on Dhaka-Kolkata, Bandhan Express ... Read more

Man, nephew killed by lightning

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A man and his nephew were struck by lightning in Satarbari village of Longair union under Gafargaon upazila of Mymensingh yesterday. The deceased were identified as Sohel Mondol, 40, a trader of pharmaceutical drugs, and his nephew Razib Mondol, 35 a rice trader in the village. Quoting locals, Raju Ahmed, officer-in-charge ... Read more

TV sales decline despite World Cup: Is streaming to blame?

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The ICC Cricket World Cup 2023 captures the attention of sports enthusiasts across the world and an intriguing trend is emerging in Bangladesh’s television market. While events of this magnitude have traditionally led to an increase in TV sales, recent figures from September show a 30% decline compared to the same ... Read more

Heritage volunteers visit Paharpur archaeological museum

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The heritage volunteers participating in UNESCO World Heritage Volunteers Programme 2023 visited Paharpur archaeological museum in Naogaon on Friday. The ten-day workshop programme organised by Nagar Upakhyan-Perceive started on October 1, said a press release. The Heritage volunteers’ team visited Paharpur archaeological museum which is on the UNESCO World Heritage tentative ... Read more

Child among three dead as mud walls collapsed in rain in Gazipur

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Three people including an eight-year-old child died in separate incidents of mud walls collapsing during heavy rain in Sadar and Kaliakoir upazilas of Gazipur. The deceased are Faridul Islam, 8, son of Matiur Rahmon of Konabari Baimile under Sadar upazila, and Imarat Hossain, 65, and his wife Achia Begum, 56, of ... Read more