Friday, March 29, 2024

What the political parties are promising us: Pros & Cons

Commentary

Mahmud ur Rahman Choudhury

All eyes and minds are riveted on the politics of the Country with the major political combines of BNP and AL in a tizzy over the upcoming polls. BNP and AL have issued their manifestos on 12 and 13 December respectively, promising everyone every conceivable and some inconceivable things too. Well, it remains to be seen how many of these promises will be fulfilled but if the past is any guide, right after the ceremonies are over it will be business as usual, meaning that there will be a government but little governance and there will be a parliament but little democracy.
Before going into a discussion of the pros and cons of the election manifestos, it is necessary to mention that the BNP and AL are mass political parties, the oldest ones in the Country, well attuned to the times and the demands, hopes and aspirations of millions of people of this Country. It ought therefore, to come as no surprise that both these parties would address the major issues with which the people of the Nation are concerned about.
The BNP and AL cannot stand to be compared with each other but as the “public”, compare we must, weigh each against the other and then vote for one or the other. The difference between these two parties do not lie in the issues that they have addressed where there is a surprising commonality; the difference lies in their “paradigms”, in the way that they see and approach politics, government and governance but more of this later after we have had a look at what all the parties have promised in their election manifestos.
The election manifestos: Pros and Cons.
The BNP and AL election manifestos are basically programmes of action which broadly tells us that they are going to contain inflation and keep prices of commodities low, that they are going to vitalize industries and agriculture, that they are going to ensure for us our basic right of food, shelter, clothing, education and health, that they aim not to reduce poverty but to eliminate it, that they are going to ensure employment for the masses of young people, that they are going to ensure food and energy security, that they are going to tackle militancy and terrorism, that they are going to ensure good governance through reduction of corruption, through changes in political culture, through transparency and accountability of public administration, through allowing the judiciary to function affectively and independently, through making the parliament affective and through implementation of local government and that through all these measures they are going to ensure social, economic and political equity and justice for the people of this Nation. Besides these concrete aspects, the BNP and AL manifesto contain a few pages of populist propaganda which is not as bad as it sounds because as mass political parties, they need to appeal both to emotions as well as to logic; fortunately though there is more of logic than emotion, more of substance than of bluster. These are all the pros of the BNP and AL election manifestos.
Coming to the cons, it needs to be said that the BNP and AL have somehow felt it necessary to unveil their manifestos in a 5 star hotel in Dhaka where only the “elites” of the civil society, the intellengencia, the foreign diplomatic corps and the media were allowed in, amid tight security. This is rather a contradiction in terms, if the BNP and AL still lay claims to being mass political parties – the masses in their teeming millions are out there in thousands of villages and small towns and it is to them that the BNP and AL “message” has to be carried to. It would have been much more becoming of these parties that the first ones to know of the manifestos are the people who will vote the parties in and out of government.
Except for a few rhetorical sentences, the BNP and AL have scrupulously avoided telling us what they are going to do about our corruption-ridden, inefficient and ineffective Judiciary, Police, Public Administration, Bureaucracy and a Military which makes a grab for political power every once in a while, for without a through-going reform in these, social, economic and political equity and justice which the parties promise in their manifesto is not going to come about.
The greatest of the cons however, is that these programmes of action, which the BNP and AL promise, will raise the expectations and hopes of the people for a better, brighter future and if these are not implemented, there will be a political and social backlash which will tear apart the polity. The consequences of not fulfilling expectations after they have been raised, can be devastating as the BNP and AL know well enough.
The ideological chasm between the BNP and AL

There is of course no denying the fact that the ideological divide between the AL and BNP is unbridgeable. While the AL insists on secularist democracy imbued with the “Spirit of the Liberation War”, the BNP emphasizes on religious ideals of Islam as a guiding factor of Bangladeshi nationalism and politics. Both points of view have their ardent, committed and entrenched supporters, almost in equal numbers, among the intellectuals, academics and the media. The masses too are equally divided between the AL and BNP but whether the masses understand the conflicting ideologies is difficult to say, particularly when these complex ideological underpinnings are reduced to populist political slogans of pro-Indian and anti-Islam (AL) on the one hand and anti-Indian and pro-Islam (BNP) on the other. Such reductionist approach to politics is a certain recipe for violent conflict.
The problem however, is that this basic issue of “secularist” and “Islamist” ideological approach cannot be resolved without conflict because they are so mutually exclusive that even a space and a language does not exist for a dialogue between the proponents of the two approaches. Each approach touches upon the entire gamut of political, economic and social institutions and relationships existing within the polity. Each approach calls for a redefinition of national identity and so, both AL and BNP attempt to monopolize political power in order to push through their own versions of “identity redefinition”. The people and the Nation are quite literally “torn” between these two conflicting ideologies providing justification to the idea that Bangladesh might well turn into a “torn state” like Pakistan, if the path to democracy is not rapidly widened and smoothed.
Concluding remarks
The unveiling of the BNP and AL election manifestos has been a great media show but what of the people for whom all this is supposedly meant? I apprehend that the people will continue to live with their poverty, their deprivations, their frustrations and their anger, as they have lived for the past 1000 years. These one thousand years have seen states and governments, kings and queens, leaders and politicians come and go without in the least bit touching upon and meaningfully improving the lives and living of the millions of people who have lived and still continue living in the geographical space now called Bangladesh. Sounds pessimistic, does it not but if we are to change all these, we must first of all get together, inspite of our politicians. This voting on 29 December 2008 could be the first step toward the changes we are all looking forward to. So let’s get together and make it happen on 29 December 2008.

Courtesy: thebangladeshtoday.com

Related News

Social media pressure changing news making

Opinion Afsan Chowdhury THE relentless reality of social media has begun to influence news making at several levels. Three social media elements are making these pressures so strong. (a) It reaches consumers almost instantly and in no way can professional media compete with that. (b) Content creators can mix and offer audio-visuals that cost little ... Read more

Securing water for sustainable urban future

Opinion By AKM Mahmudul Haque WATER, the essence of life, is a precious resource that sustains our planet and its inhabitants. Yet, despite the vastness of our oceans, only a small portion of the water is potable. Recent studies have revealed alarming statistics that approximately 80 per cent of the water supplied in cities and ... Read more

We need to transform social norms for gender equality

World Population Day Views Md Nuruzzaman Khan World Population Day, which has been observed on July 11 every year since 1989, holds significant importance in addressing critical population-related issues. This year, the focus is on gender equality, symbolised by the theme of “Unleashing the power of gender equality: Uplifting the voices of women and girls ... Read more

Quality education for all, but quality schools for few?

Views Mohammad Ehsanul Islam Khan Education empowers and shapes nations. Increased enrollment and reading levels in Bangladesh have also enhanced education access. But the focus on quantity has overtaken the drive for quality education, leaving only a handful with access to top-notch universities. According to Dr John Dewey, “Education is not preparation for life; education ... Read more

Equal education leads to a better society

Opinion Mehreen Chowdhury EDUCATION is known to be strongest when voices and diverse perspectives are heard and shared around the community. It is vital that young people are given the space and safety to express them without feeling ashamed. The idea of special education is governed by the concept that education is for all. It ... Read more

Alarming increase in child marriage

Opinion Zillur Rahaman CHILD marriage is one of the social ills in Bangladesh. It was once an epidemic in Bangladesh. It, however, came under control because of various measures and the supervision of the government in the past decade or so, but has been increasing at an alarming rate since the Covid pandemic, which increased ... Read more

Time to prioritise social justice

Views We have the chance to reshape the world we live in – economically, socially, and environmentally. Gilbert F Houngbo May 1 is widely known as International Labour Day, a day when we celebrate the contribution of workers worldwide. It is a moment for pride, celebration, and hope. After three years of the Covid-19 crisis, ... Read more

More heatwaves are coming our way. Are we prepared?

Views While Bangladesh has a lot of experience in tackling cyclones and floods, we have not taken heat stress into consideration until now. Saleemul Huq The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) recently completed its sixth assessment report (AR6), with the Synthesis Report coming out in March. The Synthesis Report carries some key messages about ... Read more

Women must be at the forefront of the transition to a low-carbon economy

Opinion Veronica Mendizabal Joffre and Pinky Serafica Can we truly reimagine a path to a low-carbon transition and change the climate narrative? This is hard to envision when we witness the unprecedented damage we are inflicting on the planet. For women, the effects of climate change are already a lived experience. Where environments are damaged ... Read more

Why collaboration is in our collective interest

ViewsRMG NOTESClimate ActionWithout fashion retailers and their suppliers working together, our industry as a whole will continue to see emissions rising. Mostafiz Uddin According to the latest report of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the world is likely to fail to reach its most ambitious climate target – limiting global warming to ... Read more

Will our universities survive in 25 years?

Views Syed Saad Andaleeb Quality education is the backbone of a wholesome and prosperous society. But finding the “quality” in quality education continues to be elusive in Bangladesh. The “so called” universities (more like community colleges) are rife with social, economic, political and ideological problems that work against building learning organisations. Teachers, the kingpins, don ... Read more

Can teachers be the pivot of change in education?

Views Manzoor Ahmed “No system of education can be better than its teachers” is an aphorism that remains meaningful. The nostalgic and idealised image of the teacher as a scholar, dispensing knowledge and wisdom to the young selflessly, who lives a simple life with little concern for material rewards and who is looked upon by ... Read more

Climate loss and damage are clearly visible in southwest Bangladesh

Views Ashish Barua, Sawkat Chowdhury The Sixth Assessment Report (AR6) by Working Group I of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) shows that the sea level, over the last 120 years, has increased by 0.20 metres, and continues rising fast, caused by thermal expansion, glacier ice loss, ice sheet loss, etc. The sea level ... Read more

How can Dhaka solve its traffic problem?

Views Debra Efroymson If I had a dollar for every time I’ve heard that “traffic was particularly bad today,” I could have retired already. Over the years, people have hazarded various suggestions as to the cause of the terrible Dhaka traffic and its potential solutions. Causes include: not enough roads for all the cars; poor ... Read more

Celebrating 50 years of global environmental movement

Opinion Saleemul Huq The global environmental movement started in 1972, with the first global environment conference held in Stockholm, Sweden, hosted by then Swedish Prime Minister Olof Palme. Among the heads of governments who also attended was the then Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, who famously declared that environment and poverty were two major global issues ... Read more

Saving earth from disasters

Opinion By Md Zillur Rahaman TODAY is World Earth Day. The day is celebrated worldwide each year to show support for the protection of the environment. It was first observed in 1970 and is now held globally by the Earth Day Network. The UN-sponsored conference in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, from June 3 to June 14, ... Read more

Women for women

Opinion Faria Rashid PATRIARCHAL societies like to deceive women into thinking that women cannot get along, work together and stand in support of one another. Given the patriarchal history of society, it has mostly worked to keep women in their places and apart from each other. This is why we hear so much about women ... Read more

CSR and a new order of business

From being seen as mere philanthropy and ‘doing good’, corporate social responsibility is now at the heart of business sustainability and ethical and accountable corporate behaviour Bitopi Das Chowdhury CSR or corporate social responsibility has been a buzz phrase for quite some time now. Not a day goes by without it being mentioned, albeit in ... Read more

Harmful impacts of cartels on consumers

Munshi Abdul Ahad A cartel is an anti-competitive arrangement between two or more competing businesses. Anticompetitive agreements, particularly cartels, harm consumers in urbanised society, as well as in the emerging countries. In adding together, cartelised industrial sectors lack competition which certainly reduces competitiveness in the long run and may have a negative impact on the ... Read more

How to troubleshoot the economy

Sadiq Ahmed Bangladesh is facing serious macroeconomic challenges and I have written a lot explaining them in a series of articles published in The Daily Star and in The Financial Express. In this new article I am going to write specifically about how Bangladesh could address those challenges while also mobilising substantial external financing in ... Read more