Friday, November 15, 2024

Mix of progress, protection

Farm sector, major environmental initiatives, hugely expanded social safety net set proposed budget big-spending
Finance Minister AMA Muhith proved his reputation of being a straight talker when he placed his maiden budget for the new government in parliament yesterday that explicitly aimed at protecting the domestic industry and at the same time laid down the path for agricultural growth.
His vision of having a socially correct budget was also spelled out in his record 122-page budget speech as safety net programmes were extended.
Both the targets looked appropriate at a time of uncertainty when all predictions indicate a deepening of global recession fallout next year. But his seemingly over dependence on investment coming from whitening of undeclared money looks equally inappropriate.
But in doing so, he has also laid some mines that may pose difficulties.
Muhith’s budget vision was of an economy that is domestically vibrant with a wide spectrum of industries beginning from big industries like pharmaceuticals to small and cottage ones receiving duty protection.
But that will increase both the average nominal protection rate and effective rate of protection because of dispersion in duties and other factors. The nominal protection rate has already increased to 21 percent this year. This time, the proposal of 5 percent regulatory duty, hikes in customs duty and addition of two more slabs of supplementary duty at 30 percent and 45 percent will push protection rate even further. Whether it is bad or good and whether this will coerce with the WTO rules is something to be seen.
He has mentioned a waft of labour intensive sectors that would get priority in the government’s book.
Although Muhith has not explicitly said anything about the export sector, he has mentioned a Tk 5,000 crore stimulus package in next budget, a cut of which would go to export industries. Such provision also shows his clear reading of the recession trends.
The emphasis on private sector’s role was spelled out in the assessment that an investment of $28 billion would be required to attain a projected growth of 8 percent by FY14 and this has to come from the private sector. His proposal for involving the private sector through Public Private Partnership and allocation of Tk 2,500 crore including Tk 300 crore seed money for risky involvement are well thought out.
But that the finance minister is genuinely concerned about his proposed big expenditure — 21 percent higher than this year’s revised budget — has been explicitly spelled out in his speech when he said: “We are particularly concerned about the possible implementation snags because of the ambitious size of ADP for the next fiscal year.” The good side is he has also proposed some ways to strengthen the Tk 30,500 crore Annual Development Programme (ADP). His promise to monitor implementation of ADP of 10 ministries which spend 78 percent of the ADP is an overdue action. Such prioritised monitoring along with plan to increase efficiency of project directors (PDs) will go a long way. However, he remained a bit on the vague side regarding how he would enhance PDs efficiency. One reason that throws the spanner here is frequent transfers of PDs and he has not said whether he would check it.
But Muhith’s proposed budget reads more like a strategic paper than a document that should have been more specific about the next year’s target. This is disheartening to many to some extent when expectations are high, but then he has rationalised by saying “I can assure you that this budget is only the beginning of the positive actions of the government”.
Muhith has clarified some major issues and left unclear some others. He has dispelled the air of confusion about shifting to five-year planning from poverty reduction strategy, which he said would continue till 2011. This would clear the cloud about donor support. However he has left unexplained what the amendments to public procurement act and rules would be.
How sustainable are the 21 percent expenditure growth and a 15 percent revenue growth projections are open to discussion. And the projected 11.6 percent revenue-GDP ratio is also not very encouraging.
The proposed budget has rightly emphasised the agriculture sector and took in the reality of price decrease to subsidy to Tk 3,600 crore next fiscal year from this fiscal year’s Tk 5,785 crore. And he has put in new ideas like expanding agricultural land, new seed development, agri research and storage. His promise to increase agri loans and up procurement target will keep the farmers happy. His budget proposals reflect that the Awami League government does not want gamble with food production and will go a long way in this.
About energy, a key growth enabler, the budget speech does not make much clear promises about what to expect next year but goes on to explain the policy it is following like opting for importing power and going for coal-based power plants. Two specific steps — introducing energy saving bulbs and advancing clock — do not instil enough confidence.
The finance minister also showcased the socially gentle face of his government by enhancing allocations for various ongoing safety net programmes like allowances for poor lactating mothers and destitute women. He has however left it unclear whether the 100-Day Employment Generation Programme renamed ‘Employment Generation for the Hardcore Poor’ will be geographically targeted on priority basis as the finance ministry wants and opposed by the food ministry.
Despite his high pro-industrialisation policy, Muhith has thrown a somehow dampening effect when he said state-owned enterprises may not be divested in the next fiscal year. His promise of arranging alternative jobs for displaced workers of any divested SOE may prove a double-edged sword. Recent privatisation experiences have shown displaced workers in poor countries suffer a lot leading to many social disorders. But the question remains whether and how ensuring alternative jobs is possible.
On the macro sides, the finance minister sounded logical when he predicted a lower GDP growth of 5.5 percent, lower than this year’s expected 5.9 percent. If the recession fallout starts, growth would decline despite a high 21 percent projected expenditure. However, such high spending is unlikely because of an ADP implementation shortfall. And in such a case, his projected fiscal deficit of 5 percent of GDP would be lower.
But his projection of external financing to the extent of 2 percent of GDP looks ambitious and if it is not possible to rope in such a huge amount of foreign financing, the government’s domestic financing will turn high. In times of recession, domestic savings growth is likely to slow down because of lower 5.5 GDP growth. This will lead to difficulty in non-bank borrowing that has been projected to increase by about 9 percent. In such a situation, bank borrowing will increase — it has already been projected a huge 57 percent higher from this fiscal year’s revised budget.
Now this may increase inflationary pressure despite a desired low fiscal deficit of 5 percent and lower private investment opportunities. Already, non-food inflation is again on the rise because of global environment.
The budget’s proposal to allow whitening undisclosed money will be a focal point of criticism for many reasons. First, this is always a discouraging move for honest taxpayers. Secondly, the meagre 10 percent tax payment on undisclosed money is too meagre. Thirdly, allowing this for three years and in a waft of sectors is questionable. And fourthly, it has not been cleared whether this opportunity is allowable for the wealth accumulated for the past years or it is also applicable for future income. If future income is included income tax collection will fall flat. Muhith himself has said import duty accounting for 42 percent of total tax may go down because of recession. If income tax also falters, revenue collection and an ambitious expenditure plan may all go haywire.

Courtesy of The Daily Star

Related News

Sajek, Khagrachari now open to visitors after being closed for over a month

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The tourism restriction imposed in Sajek valley of Rangamati and Khagrachhari for over a month was lifted today allowing visitors after 45 days. Rangamati Deputy Commissioner Mosharraf Hossain Khan announced the lifting of travel bans at the popular Sajek Union in Baghaichhari Upazila. Similarly, the Khagrachari Deputy Commissioner has also lifted ... Read more

Tourist access to suspend in St Martins in February

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The government has decided that tourist access to Saint Martin’s Island will be suspended in February to protect the island’s fragile ecology and ensure environmental preservation. Tourists will be allowed to visit the island from November to January, with overnight stays prohibited in November. In December and January, tourists can stay ... Read more

Public univs to accommodate 37pc GPA 5 achievers

Shahin Akhter Around 63 per cent of examinees securing a Grade Point Average of 5 in this year’s Higher Secondary Certificate and equivalent examinations will not be able to get admitted to the public universities across the country due to lack of seats. Though the private universities in the country have sufficient seats to accommodate ... Read more

297 killed by lightning in eight months

News Desk : dhakamirror.com At least 297 people have been killed and 73 injured in incidents of lightning strikes across the country between February and September this year, according to Save the Society and Thunderstorm Awareness Forum (SSTAF). In the eight months, lightning strikes killed 152 people while they were doing agricultural works, SSTAF said ... Read more

Flood death toll climbs to 59, over 5.4 million affected

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Fifty-nine people, including 41 men, six women and 12 children, died in the devastating flood as deaths of five more people were reported on Saturday. So far, 14 deaths have been reported in Cumilla, six in Chattogram, 23 in Feni, nine in Noakhali, three in Cox’s Bazar, and one each in ... Read more

Flood death toll reaches 13, 4.5m affected in 11 districts

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Around 13 people have been killed and 4.5 million affected by floods in 11 districts of Bangladesh, the disaster management and relief ministry said Friday, reports AFP. Thousands of people awaiting emergency rescue remained beyond electricity and mobile network coverage as a flash flood unleashed by heavy rains and an onrush ... Read more

Bangladesh ex-prime minister Khaleda Zia freed

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Former prime minister and BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia has been officially released. Former prime minister and BNP Chairperson Khaleda Zia was released on Tuesday, a day after Sheikh Hasina’s resignation as PM and fleeing the country amid an unprecedented student-led mass uprising against her authoritarian regime. The decision was revealed ... Read more

Eid-ul-Azha on June 17

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The holy Eid-ul-Azha will be celebrated in Bangladesh on June 17 (Monday) as the crescent moon of the Zilhaj month was sighted in Bangladesh’s sky on Friday evening (7 June). The National Moon Sighting Committee came up with the decision after reviewing information about the sighting of the moon at a ... Read more

Cyclone Remal: 40 dead animals found, 17 rescued hurt in Sundarbans

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The forest department officials on Tuesday said that so far they found 39 dead deer and a pig in the Sundarbans after the severe cyclone Remal that hit the forest on Sunday. Primarily they have estimated infrastructural damage of Tk 6.27 crore in the forest while the total damage, including animals ... Read more

Cyclone Remal claims at least 14 lives, affects nearly 37.58 lakh people in 19 districts

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Following its devastating impact into Bangladesh on Sunday night, Cyclone Remal has affected over 37.58 lakh people in 19 districts and taken at least 14 lives. While the cyclone has weakened into a deep depression, hundreds of villages in the southern parts of the country remain submerged. The Bangladesh Meteorological Department ... Read more

Alert issued as Cyclone Remal develops

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A weather alert has been issued by the Bangladesh Meteorological Department (BMD) as a low-pressure system in the southwest and west central Bay of Bengal gains strength, potentially developing into Cyclone Remal by Saturday. The system, currently moving northeastward, is expected to transform into a depression by early Friday. By Saturday, ... Read more

Cyclone ‘Remal’ likely to hit Bangladesh coasts on 26 May: Meteorologist

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Cyclone Remal is likely to make landfall between 6:00am and 12:00pm on 26 May in Bangladesh, affecting coastal areas from the Barguna in Barishal Division to Cox’s Bazar in the Chattogram Division, a meteorologist said today (21 May). The front of the cyclone may begin to enter coastal areas after 6:00am, ... Read more

5 consecutive days holiday for Eid-ul-Adha

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Government employees are scheduled to get five consecutive days off on Eid-ul-Azha. This includes two days of weekly holidays (Friday and Saturday) followed by another three days for Eid, according to government holiday list. Eid-ul-Azha is likely to be celebrated on June 17 this year.

Heavy rains, storms forecast for entire week

Schools open today after heatwave closures News Desk : dhakamirror.com The Bangladesh Meteorological Department (BMD) forecasts heavy rainfall with thunderstorms across the country this week, starting on Tuesday and lasting through Saturday. As per the analysis of mathematical model of rainfall index, Bangladesh is likely to witness heavy to very heavy rainfall with thunderstorms starting ... Read more

Waiting for the rain

Tawsia Tajmim As the sun blazes relentlessly, desperate craving rises for rain, for nothing soothes Mother Nature quite like its cool embrace. After a brutal month-long heatwave, residents of Chattogram, Sylhet, and Dhaka finally caught a break with some rain on 2 May. However, the downpour was not strong enough to completely wash away the ... Read more

Hajj registration extended till Jan 18

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The government, in a notice issued yesterday, extended the Hajj registration deadline for 2024 until January 18. It said aspiring Hajis would have to primarily deposit Tk 2.05 lakh, while the rest should be paid by February 29 for final registration. One has to pay Tk 5,78,840 under the general package, ... Read more

Dense fog disrupts communications across Bangladesh

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Cold and dense fog continued to disrupt life with road, air and waterways communication remaining suspended in the early hours of Tuesday as Bangladesh braces for this winter’s first cold wave likely to set in today. Authorities also confirmed until Tuesday the death of 14 people in cold-related diseases and road ... Read more

27,000 GPA 5 achievers not to get seat in public universities

Shahin Akhter Over 27,000 GPA 5 achievers in this year’s HSC and equivalent examinations cannot be admitted to the public universities due to fewer seats. A total of 92,595 examinees secured GPA 5 out of total 10,67,852 passed in the Higher Secondary Certificate examinations this year. But there are around 65,400 seats at the public ... Read more

Magnitude 5.5 earthquake jolts Dhaka, other parts of Bangladesh

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A magnitude 5.5 earthquake struck Bangladesh this morning, the United States Geological Survey said, with no immediate reports of damage. The earthquake jolted different parts of the country including Dhaka around in Ramganj of Cumilla at 9:35am, reports The Daily Star quoting Meteorologist Rubayet Kabir of Bangladesh Meteorological Department. The quake ... Read more

250cc Bajaj Pulsar N250 launched in Bangladesh

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Uttara Motors, the manufacturer and distributor of Bajaj motorcycles in Bangladesh, has recently launched The Pulsar N250 motorcycle. Pulsar N250 comes with a price tag of Tk339,999 and is available in three different colours. The motorcycle with a 250 cc oil-cooled engine has got dual channel antilock braking system (ABS). Indian ... Read more