Grameen Bank on Joy’s letter

Sajeeb Wajed Joy, son of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, has riddled Grameen Bank with allegations of tax evasion, fraud and illegal activities under its founder Muhammad Yunus, prompting the microlender to issue a firm rebuttal.
In a statement yesterday, the “Bank for the Poor” disputed Joy’s letter, published in a section of the press and said the “news contains a number of inaccurate facts and appears to be misconceived”.
Joy, who lives in the US, has written and signed an open letter full of rants against the Nobel-winning organisation. In the letter initially circulated by email, Joy has identified himself as an adviser to the prime minister.
“Last year Norwegian Television uncovered documents revealing massive financial improprieties at Grameen Bank under Muhammad Yunus. Approximately $100 million in donor funds to Grameen Bank were transferred out of Grameen Bank to a private corporation, Grameen Kalyan set up by Yunus,” Joy said.
“The government of Norway raised this as a major concern and as a compromise $30 million was returned. The remaining approximately $70 million was never returned. All correspondence in this regard was from Yunus himself,” he said.
“Just as international lobbying and media is being used in this recent incident, no doubt Yunus lobbied the Norwegian government as well. However, their explanation left millions of dollars unaccounted for.”
Joy said this became a major issue in Bangladesh and the government was forced to form an independent committee to investigate. “Yunus personally gave a press statement (no questions were allowed) where he announced that he undertook these transfers to avoid taxes, which constitutes tax evasion.”
“However, this makes no sense since Grameen was at the time a non-profit and paid no taxes. What is clear is that this transfer is completely illegal and constitutes a criminal offence of ‘conversion’ under Bangladesh law.”
“Further investigation uncovered other fraud, improprieties and illegal activity at Grameen Bank under Yunus.”
Joy said, between 1998 and 2002 all microloan borrowers were forced to pay an additional amount labelled “forced savings” which they were supposed to be paid back. “However, this money was never returned to the borrowers, who are among the poorest of society! This is fraud and theft.”
He alleged that donor funds were used to invest in a variety of private-for-profit ventures, all without approval from either the donors or the government, which owns 25 percent of Grameen Bank.
“In several cases, the equity in these private ventures was held not by Grameen Bank, but by Yunus and his family members personally. This is completely illegal and constitutes embezzlement,” Joy claimed.
He said loans were made by Grameen Bank to some of these corporations, which is completely illegal since Grameen Bank is not a regular bank. “It is lending donor funds and is only allowed to loan to microcredit borrowers.”
Joy also claimed Grameen charges up to 30 percent interest rate on loans and up to an additional 10 percent in “forced savings” to the poorest sections of society. “Their collection methods are draconian and collection officers who fail to collect payment have the uncollected amounts deducted from their pay.”
“There are many documented cases which constitute abuse and the criminal offence of ‘molestation’ under Bangladesh law,” Joy wrote in the letter.
He claimed the government, not Yunus, founded Grameen Bank. “Contrary to the popular perception, Yunus did not found Grameen Bank. The government of Bangladesh did. Initially the government owned 65 percent of Grameen Bank, which was whittled down over the years by Yunus. The government still owns 25 percent of Grameen Bank and retains the right to veto management appointees.”
Joy said there is little evidence that showed a link between microcredit and reduction of poor people. “Despite the hype, there is no evidence that microcredit has in fact reduced the rolls of the poor in Bangladesh. Grameen Bank has been in the microcredit business for 30 years, yet Bangladesh remains one of the poorest countries in the world.”
“Furthermore, the private sector investments made using Grameen Bank money have become quite profitable. Grameen Phone is by far the largest telecommunications operator in Bangladesh with a subscriber base of 28 million, annual revenue of over $1 billion and profits of several hundred million dollars per year. Grameen Bank owns 35 percent equity in Grameen Phone, so why do they have to charge such high interest rates to the poor?”
Joy also said the government had tried to retain the respect of Yunus. “Given his stature as a Nobel Prize winner, the government of Bangladesh requested that Yunus step down quietly from the post of managing director of Grameen Bank. He refused and has engaged in an international lobbying campaign accusing our government and in particular, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina of engaging in political retribution.”
“Nothing could be further from the truth. Yunus has no political stature in Bangladesh. During the brief military regime from 2007-08, under a state of emergency with all political activity banned and most political leaders behind bars, even with the help of the military he was unable to put together a political party and garner any public support. Politically he is a non-entity in Bangladesh and no threat to any political leader,” Joy said.
Grameen Bank responded to each issue in Joy’s letter. It referred to one of his allegations that “approximately $100 million in donor funds were transferred out of Grameen Bank to a private corporation, Grameen Kalyan set up by Yunus”. The microlender insisted that Grameen Kalyan is not a private corporation set up by Prof Yunus.
“Grameen Kalyan was created by the board of directors of Grameen Bank [Board Decision 42.8, dated April 25, 1996] for the benefit of Grameen borrowers and employees [90 percent of whom come from low income families],” Grameen said.
“Empowered by a board decision and executing an agreement between Grameen Bank and Grameen Kalyan, an endowment to the extent of around Tk 3,917 million was created by simultaneous notional ‘transfer’ of fund. Grameen Kalyan was never given the control and possession of the funds,” the microlender said.
Grameen said Joy’s claim that the government was “forced” to create an “independent investigation committee” was highly misleading, as the government appointed a “review committee” to look into the operations of Grameen and its associated companies.
According to Grameen, Joy’s claim about tax exemption does not take into account the tax exemption practice prevailing at that time. “There are perfectly legal ways to minimise tax liabilities. They do not constitute ‘evasion’,” it said.
The claim that “Grameen was, at the time, non-profit and paid no taxes” is simply not true, the microfinance institution insisted. “Grameen Bank was never a non-profit organisation. Following the expiry of Grameen Bank’s tax-exempt status on December 31, 1996, it did not receive notice of tax-exempt status until 2000, when the government retroactively issued tax-exempt status to Grameen Bank from 1997 onwards,” it said.
Grameen brushed aside Joy’s claim that from 1998 to 2002, “forced savings” were taken in members’ names and not returned to them.
“From the beginning of Grameen Bank’s operation, members have been required to maintain a savings account containing five percent of their loan disbursement amount in order to provide for their emergency needs,” Grameen said.
“This money is credited to the borrowers’ savings account, which is an interest bearing account and Grameen Bank has been giving 8.5 percent interest for the savings. The borrowers are enjoying the benefit of their savings at their convenience and are allowed to withdraw the entire savings without leaving any balance in their accounts. There is no question of not returning the money to the account holders,” Grameen added.
According to Grameen, the allegation of using donors’ funds for private ventures without approval from either the donors or the Grameen Bank is completely false and baseless. “There had never been any single incident of using Grameen Bank fund for private venture with or without approval of the Grameen Bank,” it said.
Grameen also refuted a claim that it had charged a high interest rate. “Grameen Bank charges the lowest interest rate in Bangladesh for microcredit,” the microfinance organisation said.
Joy’s letter, according to ‘Friends of Grameen’, has exposed the very dynamics behind the attacks on Yunus and Grameen Bank.
On March 15, a full bench of Supreme Court will hear an appeal filed by the Nobel laureate against a High Court verdict that upheld a central bank order removing Keep on reading

Related News

BMD predicts rain in Ctg, Sylhet today

News Desk : Amid the scorching heatwave, Bangladesh Meteorological Department (BMD) predicted rain in Chattogram and Sylhet today. “Rain or thundershower accompanied by temporary gusty wind may occur at one or two places in Chattogram and Sylhet divisions in the next 24 hours starting 6:00pm on Monday,” said BMD. The weather may remain mainly ... Read more

Primary section in secondary schools to close too

New Desk : The government today decided to close the primary section attached with the secondary schools till June 8 due to the ongoing heatwave. The government also instructed the authorities to suspend the assembly session at all schools. Additionally, the Directorate of Secondary and Higher education (DSHE) instructed all the educational institutions not ... Read more

Hero Alom picks up nomination papers for Dhaka-17 by election

News Desk : Ashraful Hossain Alam, known as Hero Alam, will contest the by-election to the Dhaka-17 constituency, scheduled for 17 July, which fell vacant following the death of actor Akbar Hossain Pathan Farooque. He collected the nomination paper from the Election Commission (EC) office in Dhaka on Sunday (4 June). Hero Alom said ... Read more

Mob beats, stabs youth over Facebook post, 10 cops injured

News Desk : A shopkeeper was beaten and stabbed by a mob in front of Police Staff College in the capital’s Mirpur-13 yesterday for allegedly hurting religious sentiments. A team of Kafrul Police Station rescued and sent him to Dhaka Medical College Hospital around 9:45pm, said Saddam Hossain, sub-inspector of the police station. “Someone ... Read more

Government primary schools will remain closed from tomorrow until June 8 due to heatwave

News Desk : Due to the severe heatwave in the country, the government has decided to keep all public primary schools closed from June 5th to 8th. The decision was taken considering the health safety of the children going to the schools, the Ministry of Primary and Mass Education said in a press release ... Read more

Community clinics will offer hypertension and diabetic drugs

News Desk : Drugs for hypertension and diabetes will now be available in community clinics across the country as part of the government’s plan to ensure primary health care in rural areas. The drug list update committee for community clinics has taken the decision in a meeting on May 14, 2023, according to a ... Read more

Odisha train accident: Identities of 2 injured Bangladeshis confirmed

News Desk : Two Bangladeshi citizens from Rajshahi and Bogura are among the injured in India’s one of the worst rail disasters in Odisha last night. Of the injured, Russel-uz Zaman, 27, from Rajshahi was a passenger of Chennai-bound Coramandel Express from Shalimar near Kolkata, a senior official of Bangladesh Deputy High Commission in ... Read more

NHRC, World Vision team up to stop violence against children

News Desk : World Vision, an international development agency dedicated to child welfare, and the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) have signed a memorandum of understanding to end all forms of violence against children and build a country free of child marriage. A MoU signing ceremony was held on 1 June with National Human ... Read more

Shyamoli building fire kills one

News Desk : A commercial building in the capital Shyamoli caught fire last night, killing one person. The identity of the approximately 45-year-old deceased could not be immediately confirmed. His body was recovered from the 17th floor of the 20-story Rupayan Shelford building, said Abdul Mannan, senior station officer of Mohammadpur Fire Station. The ... Read more

Metro to run from 8:00am to 8:00pm

News Desk : From now on the metro rail will run from 8:00am to 8:00pm six days a week. Mahfuz Rahman, manager of Dhaka Mass Transit Company Limited (DMTCL), confirmed to The Daily Star that the metro rail started following the new schedule from yesterday morning. As per the new schedule, weekly closure of ... Read more

Biman fires captain for negligence

News Desk : Biman has fired Capt Dildar Ahmed Tufail for negligence in duty while captaining a flight on January 15. He was reportedly napping in the crew rest area, leaving the cockpit of the Boeing 777-300ER technically unmanned. A passenger had a heart attack during the overnight flight to Dhaka from Jeddah. Capt ... Read more

Noab demands withdrawal of tax, duties on newsprint

News Desk : The Newspaper Owners Association of Bangladesh has demanded the withdrawal of taxes and duties on newsprint in the budget for the fiscal year 2023-24. In a press release yesterday, Noab said it made the demands during a pre-budget discussion with the National Board of Revenue. The release mentioned that NBR Chairman ... Read more

E-toll to be compulsory on 9 bridges, 2 highways from November

News Desk : The government has made Electronic Toll Collection (ETC) System compulsory at nine bridges and two highways from November. The Roads and Highways Department (RHD) issued a circular in this regard. According to the circular, the government has already installed automatic toll machines at those bridges and highways. The nine bridges are ... Read more

Boeing offers Biman its latest 787-10 Dreamliner

News Desk : After Airbus, the American manufacturer Boeing has now offered its latest model aircraft, 787-10 Dreamliner, to the Biman Bangladesh Airlines. The company sent a letter in this regard to Biman’s chairman recently which will be discussed in the board meeting on Tuesday, said Shafiul Azim, managing director of Biman. “As we ... Read more

Fishing, tourism banned in Sundarbans for 3 months

News Desk : To ensure safe breeding and movement of fish and wild animals the Forest Department will enforce a three-month ban on fishing and tourism in the Sundarbans that set to be effective from 1 June to 31 August. During this period, the movement of all types of vessels, including boats and fishing ... Read more

Biman to operate special flights from Dhaka for RU admission seekers

News Desk : Biman Bangladesh Airlines will operate three special flights on the Dhaka-Rajshahi route from May 29 to May 31 to facilitate journeys of Rajshahi University admission seekers. The RU admission tests will take in four shifts starting from 9:00am and ending at 4:30pm on May 29, 30 and 31. The flights will ... Read more

First hajj flight with 419 pilgrims leaves Dhaka on Sunday

News Desk : The first hajj flight, carrying 419 pilgrims, is scheduled to leave Hazrat Shahjalal International Airport for Saudi Arabia at around 3.20am on Sunday (May 21). “A Biman Bangladesh Airlines will operate the first hajj flight from Hazrat Shahjalal International Airport to Jeddah on Sunday at 3.20am,” Biman’s spokesperson Tahera Khondoker told ... Read more

7 Bangladeshis make Forbes 30 under 30 Asia 2023 list

News Desk : Seven Bangladeshis have made the list of ‘Forbes 30 Under 30′ Asia Class of 2023. The famous business journal, Forbes, first launched the ’30 under 30’ list in 2011, listing the thirty movers and shakers under the age of thirty. From 2016 to 2022, a total of 25 Bangladeshis were named ... Read more

Economic life of buses fixed at 20yrs, goods vehicles at 25yrs

News Desk : The government fixed the economic life of buses and minibuses at 20 years and that for goods-laden vehicles, including trucks and covered vans, at 25 years. In this regard, the Roads and Highways Division on Wednesday issued a circular which would be effective following a gazette notification. In 2010, the Bangladesh ... Read more

Fire hydrants will be installed in all DNCC markets, slums: mayor

News Desk : Mayor Atiqul Islam said fire hydrants will be installed in every slum and market under the jurisdiction of Dhaka North City Corporation (DNCC) to deal with fire incidents. He made the announcement while inaugurating a fire hydrant in Sattala slum of Mahakhali in the capital on Thursday (18 May). He stressed ... Read more