Witness the weakness

About 60pc cases suffer as witnesses unwilling to testify for intimidation, hassle; govt talks of a protection act
Zafrun Nahar had spent five years trying to have her son’s killers punished. But no witness showed up to testify at the trial.
Frustrated that all her hard work brought nothing, she now sees no point in trying. “I have waited enough…seen enough. But no more do I wait for justice,” says a battle-weary Zafrun, 61.
Her elder son Himel, 25, was shot dead on Salimullah Road in the capital’s Mohammadpur area in February 1997.
In the murder trial, 34 dates had been set for testimony of the prosecution witnesses. But no-one dared to appear in the court in the face of intimidation by the accused and their associates.
The case proceedings have been stayed by the High Court since January 14, 2002.
Fed up that the trial was going nowhere, Zafrun did not move to have the HC order vacated in last eight years.
Meantime, the accused have secured bail and three of the six eyewitnesses left the country failing to withstand intimidation.
The defendants began bullying the witnesses even before the case went to the court.
“They gathered in front of my house every night, shouting abuse,” said an eyewitness to Himel murder.
One afternoon, another witness was picked up from his office and coerced into giving a statement saying he did not see anything.
“I don’t blame the witnesses. Even I would fear for my life while returning home from the court,” Zafrun said.
“I won’t carry it anymore and won’t go to court anymore,” she added.
Currently, Zafrun is sick and suffering from various diseases. It would not be possible for her to pursue the case even if she wanted.
Lawyers say numerous are the instances where cases could not be resolved even in 20 years due to absence of witnesses. And this is one of the reasons why the courts have to grapple with a huge backlog of cases.
A ballpark estimate is that at least 60% cases in every court suffer for witnesses unwilling to testify, say some public prosecutors at Dhaka judge’s court.
According to a parliamentary sub-committee report, over 15 lakh cases were pending in subordinate courts till January.
Cases relating to women and children repression can be taken as an example. Though the cases are supposed to be settled in 180 days since their initiation, 1,426 cases including 682 in Dhaka are stuck in different courts.
“In more than half the cases, witnesses are not available. Sometimes victims are implicated in false cases so they cannot pursue the case,” said Dr Bilkis Begum, coordinator of Dhaka medical College’s One Stop Crisis Centre.
Law Minister Shafique Ahmed said, “We want to formulate a law to ensure witness protection, and have already asked the ministry to examine everything relevant.”
The problem is so acute that the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in a ruling observed that witnesses do not want to appear before court for fear of reprisals.
In this context, it said, a court can pass verdict on single evidence, provided the proof is convincing.
How many cases are hung for intimidation of witnesses cannot be known, as neither the complainants nor the witnesses file complaints with court or general diaries (GD) with police station.
“It’s no use filing a GD. The accused keep terrorising the witnesses, as police do nothing,” said Shahid Khan who has recently filed a GD with Madaripur Police Station after receiving death threats from those accused of killing his younger brother.
Sometimes it gets beyond intimidation and costs a witness his life.
On May 18, Jubo League activist Rahim was killed in Mirpur while on his way home.
Belayet, who was accompanying him and also injured in the attack, said Rahim was killed as he had seen the murder of a local Jubo League leader.
“Now it’s my turn. The killers are after me. They have been threatening me because I’m the second eyewitness to the first murder and main eyewitness to Rahim killing,” he added.
Lawyers said police rarely act on a GD, leaving the complainant exposed to intimidation and constant threat of attack.
Besides, public prosecutors do not want to cite intimidation as a reason for non-appearance of witness as that would lay bare the state’s failure.
Tawhida Khandker, director of Bangladesh National Women Lawyers Association (BNWLA), said, “Over 50 percent of our cases are making no progress, as witnesses don’t want to show up for intimidation and lack of security.”
Stressing the need for a witness protection act, BNWLA Executive Director Salma Ali said the law must seek to ensure safe shelter, various support services and treatment for victims and witnesses, and punishment to those harassing the victim or witness.
It must also provide for use of interpreter and modern technologies like teleconferencing in taking deposition.
She also said the provision for witness protection in the existing law is inadequate.
Besides intimidation, financial constraints contribute to non-appearance of witnesses, lawyers said.


Courtesy of The Daily Star

Related News

Road accidents claim 476 lives in September: report

News Desk : dhakamirror.com At least 476 people were killed in traffic accidents across the country in September, according to a report by the Road Safety Foundation. They died in 407 separate accidents, with 794 injured in the past month. Road Safety Foundation published the report on Monday (3 October) citing that of the total ... Read more

Durga Puja begins today

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Durga Puja, the biggest religious festival of the Hindu community, begins today with Maha Shashthi puja at temples across the country with due religious fervour. Preparations at all puja mandaps have almost been completed as artisans are busy giving the final touches to idols and pandals to celebrate the festival. It ... Read more

Veteran journalist Toab Khan dies

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Dainik Bangla editor and Ekushey Padak-winning journalist Toab Khan passed away. He was 87. He breathed his last around 12:40pm today at United Hospital, Sharifuzzaman Pintu, executive editor of the daily said. Toab Khan was admitted to the hospital with old-age complications, his colleagues said. Born on April 24 of 1934 ... Read more

Study shows 61% of processed foods contain too much salt

About 34% of processed foods contain double the recommended amount News Desk : dhakamirror.com About 61% of processed and packaged foods found in Bangladesh contain more salt than is considered safe, posing a higher health risk to consumers. A guideline is needed to set a maximum salt content for processed foods, health experts say. Popular ... Read more

Issuance of driving licenses to become ‘easier’ from December

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The Bangladesh Road Transport Authority plans to simplify the process for obtaining a driving license from December, , an official announced on Tuesday. To make the process simpler, the authorities will collect biometric data from applicants prior to driving tests, allow them to make payments online, and send out licenses in ... Read more

Create jobs, boost rural economy

Speakers tell event News Desk : dhakamirror.com Safeguarding children from curses of child labour and early marriage has become a challenge in the aftermath of pandemic, said speakers at a seminar in Rajshahi yesterday. They suggested job creation and boosting up rural economy for resisting the families of low-income group from forcing their children into ... Read more

Karatoa boat capsizes, death toll rises to 65

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The death toll from the boat capsize in Karatoa river in Panchagarh rose to 65 after 16 more bodies were recovered from the river today (September 27, 2022). At least 15 people are still missing from the incident. Dipankar Roy, additional deputy commissioner of Panchagarh and head of the rescue operation ... Read more

Holy Eid-e-Miladunnabi on 9 October

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Marking the day of birth and passing away of Prophet Hazrat Muhammad (PBUH), holy Eid-e-Miladunnabi will be observed in the country on October 9 with religious solemnity. The decision was made at the National Moon Sighting Committee’s meeting held yesterday at the Islamic Foundation’s office in Baitul Mukarram. The meeting was ... Read more

8 businesses including Unilever and City Group and individuals sued for overcharging

The Bangladesh Competition Commission has served notices on the company and the individual to attend hearings on 26-27 News Desk : dhakamirror.com The Bangladesh Competition Commission has filed lawsuits against eight people and businesses, including Unilever, City Group, Kazi Farms, Paragon Poultry, and Rashid Agro, alleging that they have illegally increased the cost of numerous ... Read more

Chowdhury Abdullah Al-Mamun made new IGP

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Chowdhury Abdullah Al Mamun has been appointed as the new Inspector General of Bangladesh Police. Mamun will replace the current IGP Benazir Ahmed who is going to retire on September 30, according to a notification issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs in this regard. Mamun is currently the director general ... Read more

IGP Benazir Ahmed going on retirement

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The government has issued a gazette notification on Dr Benazir Ahmed’s retirement from the post of Inspector General of Police (IGP) of Bangladesh Police (BP). The move comes as the senior cop will reach his retirement age on 30 September. According to government rules, an official goes into post-retirement leave (PRL) ... Read more

Dinajpur board’s postponed SSC exams from Oct 10-13

News Desk : dhakamirror.com SSC examinations on four subjects, which were postponed by Dinajpur Education Board, will be held from October 10 to 13. The decision was taken at an emergency meeting chaired by the education board’s chairman Prof Md Kamrul Islam. A routine in this regard has been published on the website of Dinajpur ... Read more

SSC question paper leak: Dinajpur Board postpones 4 exams

The four subjects are Mathematics, Physics, Agricultural Science and Chemistry News Desk : dhakamirror.com Secondary School Certificate (SSC) exams on total four subjects, scheduled to be held under the Dinajpur Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education, have been postponed. A notification, signed by the board’s Chairman Professor Md Kamrul Islam, was issued in this regard ... Read more

Japan allocates $3.5 mn for Rohingyas in Bangladesh

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Japan will disburse $3.5 million to UNHCR, the UN Refugee Agency, to provide protection and humanitarian assistance to Rohingyas sheltered in Bangladesh. The Japanese government and the UNHCR have signed an agreement regarding the assistance that would be used to maintain access to critical and life-sustaining services for Rohingyas living in ... Read more

UNFPA discusses child marriage, menstrual health situation

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Knowledge sharing event on child marriage during the Covid pandemic and menstrual health management in urban slums, organised by UNFPA was held on Sunday. UNFPA arranged the programme to disseminate and discuss the findings of the two studies — one to shed light on the situation of child marriage during covid-19 ... Read more

75pc fishermen face hardship during hilsa ban: study

News Desk : dhakamirror.com 75 per cent fishing workers face financial hardship during the days of hilsa ban while 79.8 per cent of the workers that face economic problem have only one earning member in their families, according to a study. The study found that those who live on fishing did not receive adequate amount ... Read more

Nurjahan group chairman jailed 1 year for selling substandard edible oil

News Desk : dhakamirror.com A Chattogram court today (September 20, 2022) sentenced Nurjahan group Chairman and Managing Director Zahir Ahammed to one year in jail and fined him Tk 2.5 lakh in a case filed by BSTI for marketing low-quality edible oil. Chattogram Metropolitan Magistrate Kazi Shariful Islam passed the order today, our Chattogram staff ... Read more

55-year-old Balayet gets chance to study journalism in Varendra University

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The 55-year-old, Md Balayet Sheikh, has qualified in the admission test of Varendra University for the academic session — Fall-2022. Balayet proved that age cannot be a barrier to education as he got the successful passed the entry test of Journalism, Communication and Media Studies at the Varendra University. Balayet said, ... Read more

BTRC to disable additional SIMs under one NID by November 30

News Desk : dhakamirror.com BTRC (Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission) will disable more than 15 SIMs registered to a single national identity (NID.) There are a total of 3.13 million such SIM cards under 7.24 million NIDs, according to the telecom regulator, and they will all be terminated by November 30. A user may register a ... Read more

Three prisoners sit SSC exams in Khagrachari Prison

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Three inmates from the Khagrachhari district jail are taking the Secondary School Certificate (SSC) exam. The three prisoners are taking exams in the jail’s office room, said AG Mahmud, jailer of the Khagrachari District Jail. SSC exams began across the nation today (September 15, 2022). One of the examinees, Sohag Alam, ... Read more