Thursday, June 13, 2024

Quader Mollah gets death penalty

The Supreme Court (SC) on Tuesday awarded the death penalty to Jamaat-e-Islami leader Abdul Quader Mollah on charges of crimes against humanity committed during the War of Liberation in 1971. A five-member bench of the Appellate Division, led by Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain, entered the courtroom at 9.32 am and delivered the 4:1 majority verdict.
The Chief Justice pronounced the verdict in a jam-packed courtroom at 9.35 am. The four other members of the bench are Justices Surendra Kumar Sinha, M Abdul Wahhab Miah, Syed Mahmud Hossain and AHM Shamsuddin Chowdhury.
This is the first time that the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court has delivered judgment on an appeal in a war crimes case.
In its short order, the apex court said, “Criminal Appeal No. 24 of 2013 filed by the Government is found to be maintainable unanimously. This appeal is allowed by majority.”
“The order of acquittal passed by the International Crimes Tribunal No. 2 in respect of charge No. 4 is set aside by majority and the respondent is found guilty of the said charge. He is sentenced to imprisonment for life on that charge,” the verdict said.
The verdict read out by the Chief Justice also said, “He is sentenced to death by the majority of 4:1 in respect of charge No. 6. He will be hanged till death. Criminal Appeal No. 25 of 2013 filed by Abdul Quader Mollah is dismissed unanimously.”
The short order also said, “The conviction in respect of charge No. 6 is maintained unanimously. The conviction and sentence passed in respect of charges No. 1, 2, 3 and 5 are maintained by majority of 4:1.”
Earlier, the International Crimes Tribunal had handed down life imprisonment to Quader Mollah for charge No. 6, which said that on the evening of March 26, 1971, Mollah had led some Biharis and Pakistani soldiers to kill one Hazrat Ali and five members of his family in Mirpur.
The highest court of the country found imprisonment for life too lenient a term for killing Hazrat Ali and his family members in Mirpur during the 1971 Liberation War and ordered that the Jamaat assistant secretary general be hanged till death.
Apart from the death sentence, Tuesday’s verdict of the Appellate Division brought another major change to the International Crimes Tribunal judgment relating to charge No. 4.
According to charge No. 4, on November 25, 1971, an organised attack and indiscriminate firing by Mollah and his cohorts killed hundreds of unarmed people of Khanbari and Ghatar Char villages in Keraniganj. Mollah was found not guilty and acquitted in respect of charge no. 4, according to the tribunal verdict.
But the apex court found Mollah guilty of killing hundreds of people at Ghatar Char and Bhawal Khan Bari in Keraniganj and awarded life-imprisonment for the offence.
However, the apex court upheld the tribunal verdict by majority (4:1) in connection with four other charges — 1, 2, 3 and 5 — brought against him on charges of crimes against humanity committed during the Liberation War.
According to charge no. 1, on April 5, 1971, Mollah had instructed Akhter Gunda, one of his aides, to kill Pallab, a student of the Bangla College and an organiser of the Liberation War.
According to charge no. 2, on March 27, 1971, Mollah and his aides had murdered pro-Liberation poet Meherun Nesa, along with her mother and two brothers, at their home
in Mirpur-6 of Dhaka.
According to charge no. 3, on March 29, 1971, Mollah, accompanied by Al-Badr, Razakars and Bihari men, had apprehended journalist Khondoker Abu Taleb and slit his throat at the Mirpur Jallad Khana Pump House.
According to charge no. 5, on April 24, 1971, Mollah had led Pakistani army personnel and around 50 Biharis to launch an attack on unarmed people of Alubdi village in Mirpur. The attack resulted in the deaths of 344 people.
Mollah, who is assistant secretary general of Jamaat-e-Islami, now stands guilty of all the six charges which the investigators had pressed against him.
Chief defence counsel, Barrister Abdur Razzaq in his immediate reaction said, “We are aggrieved, surprised, and we think the verdict is against justice”.
He mentioned that it was ‘unprecedented’ in the history of Bangladesh that the SC has awarded death penalty to Mollah although the trial court had sentenced him for life.
“We will file a review petition within 30 days of receiving the full verdict,” he added.
On the other hand, Attorney general Mahbubey Alam told reporters that there was no opportunity to file a review petition against the verdict, but the defence could seek presidential mercy.
He also said that the legal process had ended with the appeal verdict and that Molla could only seek mercy from the President.
He will be hanged if the President rejects his mercy plea.
“This special Act has been formulated by Amending the Constitution. It says the tribunal will try cases and gives opportunities for appealing against the verdict with the Appellate Division.
“The Act does not give any other opportunities. And so there is no opportunity for review,” said the Attorney General.
Law Minister Barrister Shafique Ahmed also gave the same opinion saying there was no scope for convicts tried under International Crimes (Tribunals) Act, 1973, to file petitions with the Supreme Court seeking a review of its verdict. The law minister spoke to media persons at his secretariat office while the attorney general met reporters on the Supreme Court premises soon after the verdict.
About the presidential clemency, Barrister Shafique said that before the execution of the verdict, the jail authorities would give the convict time to pray for presidential pardon. The President had the Constitutional power to grant clemency, he said.
But some eminent lawyers differed with the view of the Attorney General and the law Minister on the issue of the scope of the review.
Eminent jurist Barrister Rafique-ul Huq told The Independent that as per the Constitutional provision, there was a provision to file a review petition with the apex court within the stipulated time.
“As per the Constitutional provision as well as the Supreme Court Rules, the convict can file a review petition,” he noted.
“There is no bar to filing a review petition against the verdict as the Appellate Division’s Rules allow a convict to file a review petition within 30 days of pronouncing a verdict. If a convict files an application seeking a certified copy of the verdict, then the convict will get 30 days from the date of receiving the copy of the verdict,” he added.
Another prominent lawyer Advocate Anisul Huq said, “Although there is no provision for filing a review petition in the ICT Act, a convicted person’s fundamental and Constitutional rights allow him to file a review petition with the apex court.” As per the Constitution, a convict could file a review petition with the apex court as the Constitution was the supreme law and everyone was bound to respect the Constitution, he added.
Noted lawyer Barrister Shahdeen Malik told The Independent that a review was not a matter of rights “in the sense that a convict cannot claim a review”.
He also said, “The Appellate Division has hardly ever changed its decision on review. Hence, a review does not usually give any different result.”
Malik said that there was no result from the review petitions in the past five years.
However, he also said that there was no legal bar to filing a review petition with the apex court. Both the government and the defence had appealed against the life-imprisonment handed down on February 5.
After concluding the hearing on the appeals from both sides, the five-member bench of the Appellate Division on July 23 kept the matter for delivering the verdict.
During the appeal hearing, the chief defence counsel, barrister Abdur Razzaq, raised a legal question before the SC, arguing that the government’s appeal would not apply to Quader Mollah’s case as it was not filed in accordance with proper legal procedures.
Following this, the Appellate Division bench of the Supreme Court, on June 20, appointed seven amici curiae (friends of the court) for legal opinion on two issues — whether the trial of war crimes should fall under the purview of the international customary law and whether the amendment of the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act on February 17 should come into effect from July 14, 2009.
The seven amici curiae were TH Khan, Mahmudul Islam, Rafique-ul Huq, M Amir-Ul Islam, Rokanuddin Mahmud, AF Hasan Ariff and Ajmalul Hossain, QC.
All the amici curiae have submitted their opinions before the apex court. However, the amici curiae made contradictory statements over the issue.
The apex court appointed the lawyers following some questions raised during the hearing on the government appeal filed under the amended provision of the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act, 1973.
The government filed the appeal following an amendment to the ICT Act on February 18 that had cleared the way for filing appeal with the apex court against the tribunal’s inadequate sentencing of a convict.
Following the Shahbagh protests, the government had amended the ICT Act, providing for equal rights of appeal by both the convict and the prosecution. Earlier, the prosecution could not appeal, barring cases of acquittal of the accused. After bringing the amendment to the ICT Act, the government, on March 3, had filed an appeal with the apex court against the ICT’s verdict, seeking death penalty for war crimes convict Abdul Quader Mollah.
On March 4, a day after the government’s appeal, the defence side filed an appeal with the Supreme Court against the ICT verdict, seeking an acquittal order for Quader Mollah.
On February 5 this year, the ICT-2 handed down life imprisonment to Quader Mollah in connection with two charges.
After hearing the appeals, the apex court today rejected the convict’s plea. Since January, two war crimes tribunals have delivered verdicts in cases against six former and current Jamaat leaders. The Quader Mollah appeal case was the first one that was disposed of by majority today.

-With The Independent input

Related News

5 magnitude earthquake jolts parts of Bangladesh

News Desk : A magnitude 5 earthquake jolted a large part of the country on Sunday (2 June) afternoon., including Dhaka. The quake struck at 2:44pm from a depth of about 110km, according to the Bangladesh Meteorological Department, and was centred in the Mawlaik area of Myanmar, 441 km southeast of Dhaka. The quake ... Read more

Over 2cr to be fed as daylong Vitamin ‘A’ plus campaign begins

News Desk : The National Vitamin A-plus campaign is being conducted with a target to feed the capsules to over 2.22 crore children, aged between six months and 59 months. The campaign started at 8am on Saturday (June 1) and will continue till 4pm. Feeding Vitamin A capsules prevents blindness in children, ensures normal ... Read more

Postponed notice fake, HSC exams on June 30 as per schedule

News Desk : The Higher Secondary Certificate (HSC) and equivalent exams will be held on time as per previous announcement, beginning on 30 June. The routine deferring the exams for a month that is making rounds in social media, is fake, the Board of Intermediate and Secondary Education, Dhaka said on Saturday. A circular ... Read more

3 month-long ban on fishing, tourism in Sundarbans begins

News Desk : The forest department has imposed this three-month ban on fishing and tourism in the Sundarbans. Local communities, including fishermen, wood and honey collectors, who depend on the Sundarbans for their livelihoods, are concerned about a three-month ban on all activities in the forest starting Saturday. The restriction applies to visitors, including ... Read more

Appellate Division upholds HC verdict on DU teacher Samia’s demotion

News Desk : The Appellate Division today (26 May) upheld the judgement of the High Court which declared illegal the demotion order of Dhaka University faculty Samia Rahman on charges of plagiarism. A four-member appellate bench headed by senior judge M Enayetur Rahim of the Appellate Division rejected the appeal of DU as invalid. ... Read more

3.2 million children at risk as Cyclone Remal hits Bangladesh coasts: UNICEF

News Desk : As Cyclone Remal hit the coastal areas of Bangladesh, over 8.4 million people, including 3.2 million children, are at high health, nutrition, sanitation, and safety risks, according to UNICEF. ‘Our thoughts go out to the children and their families at this critical moment as they endure the storm’s impact,’ said UNICEF ... Read more

Classes suspended at coastal area schools due to cyclone

News Desk : No classes will be held at schools in the coastal areas due to Cyclone Remal, said State Minister for Disaster Management and Relief Mohibur Rahman. He said this after a meeting of the inter-ministerial disaster management coordination committee at the Secretariat on Sunday. According to a bulletin of the Met Office, ... Read more

Cyclone Remal forms over Bay, signal 7 at Payra and Mongla

News Desk : The deep depression over the east and west central Bay of Bengal intensified into a cyclonic storm “Remal” at around 9:00 pm today and is expected to hit the country’s coasts between 6pm and 11:59pm tomorrow, according to the Bangladesh Meteorological Department (BMD). The Met Office asked the Payra and Mongla ... Read more

Admissions for Class XI start tomorrow

News Desk : The first phase of applications for Class XI admission for the 2024–2025 academic year will begin tomorrow, May 26, and run through June 11th. According to the XI class admission circular 2024-25, the online application system is divided into three phases with designated application windows, result announcements, and confirmation periods. Students ... Read more

Exam will not be postponed for Cyclone Remal: NU

News Desk : The National University has decided not to postpone the Introduction to Government Policy exam for 4th-year Political Science honours students for the academic year 2022, despite the warning for the approaching Cyclone Remal. The exam is scheduled to be held on Sunday (26 May) at 1:00pm, the same day that the ... Read more

Gold price cut by Tk 1,084 per bhori

News Desk : The prices of gold in the country’s local market witnessed a fall on Thursday as the Bangladesh Jewellers’ Association (Bajus) slashed the price of 22-carat gold by Tk 1,084 per bhori (11.664 grammes). The new rate for the precious metal will come into effect on Friday, BAJUS said in a press ... Read more

Don’t pay anyone for visas, or work permits: Italian envoy

News Desk : Italian Ambassador to Bangladesh, Antonio Alessandro, advised visa-seekers not to pay anyone for visas, emphasising that the embassy only charges small taxes and processing fees. “Our services are free except for these official fees,” he said today (21 May) following a meeting with Shofiqur Rahman Choudhury, the State Minister for Expatriates’ ... Read more

Bangladeshi mountaineer Babar Ali conquers Everest

News Desk : Babar Ali from Chattogram has summited Mount Everest and raised the red and green flag on the world’s highest peak. He reached the summit at 8:30am local time (8:45am Bangladesh time) on Sunday, proudly raising the red and green flag of Bangladesh. He began his journey on 1 April, after necessary ... Read more

Price of gold increases by Tk1,178 per bhori

The new rate will be effective from Sunday (19 May) News Desk : The Bangladesh Jewellers Association (Bajus) today (18 May) increased the price of gold by Tk1,178 per bhori, followed by a price hike in the local bullion market. According to a Bajus statement, 22-carat gold will now cost Tk1,18,460 per bhori (11.664 ... Read more

9 Bangladeshis named in Forbes “30 Under 30 Asia” list

News Desk : Nine Bangladeshis have been named in Forbes “30 Under 30 Asia” list for their contributions across various industries. Forbes announced its prestigious “30 Under 30 Asia” list for the ninth consecutive year yesterday (15 May), showcasing 300 exceptional young individuals under the age of 30 who are making significant strides across ... Read more

SC Stays HC Verdict On Condemn Cell

News Desk : The Appellate Division on Wednesday stayed a High Court verdict that asked the jail authorities not to put death sentence inmates in the solidarity confinement before the end of all legal processes. The Appellate Division judge in chamber, Justice M Enayetur Rahim, granted the stay after hearing an appeal filed by ... Read more

BRTA to take ‘no helmet, no fuel’ policy for bikers

News Desk : Besides, no battery-run auto-rickshaws will be allowed to operate in Dhaka The Bangladesh Road Transport Authority (BRTA) has decided to take a “no helmet, no fuel” approach for motorcycle riders across the country. Besides, no battery-run auto-rickshaws will be allowed to operate in Dhaka, according to decisions taken at a meeting ... Read more

MV Abdullah finally arrives at Ctg port

News Desk : The 23 crew members of Bangladeshi flag carrier MV Abdullah, which was recently freed from the captivity of Somali pirates, has reached the Chittagong Port today (14 May). The Chittagong Port Authority has a reception at the New Mooring Container Terminal (NCT) to welcome back the sailors. Their family members are ... Read more

JnU female student gets 5 yrs in DSA case

News Desk : A Dhaka tribunal has sentenced Tithy Sarker, a suspended student of Jagannath University, to five years imprisonment in a DSA case filed for making derogatory comments about religion on Facebook. However, it has granted her a year-long probation on eight conditions, including regular care for her aged father, following traffic rules, ... Read more

Detention in condemned cells before final disposal of the case unlawful: High Court

News Desk : The High Court (HC) has ruled that it is illegal and unlawful to detain convicts in the condemned cell (blind cell) of the prison before the death sentence is finalised by the verdict of the Supreme Court’s Appellate Division. The High Court bench of Justice Sheikh Hasan Arif and Justice Md ... Read more