Sunday, October 13, 2024

Remove 2 HC judges

Demand treasury bench MPs during discussion at JS over verdict on Speaker’s ruling
In a heated discussion in parliament, a number of ruling alliance lawmakers yesterday accused two High Court judges of violating the constitution and demanded that they be removed for delivering a controversial judgment on the Speaker’s June 18 ruling.
The two — Justice Hasan Foez Siddique and Justice ABM Altaf Hossain — in a verdict recently said the Speaker’s ruling had no legal effect and was baseless in the eye of the law.
Speaker Abdul Hamid on June 18 said Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury Manik had violated the constitution by making “derogatory remarks” about the Jatiya Sangsad and the Speaker.
Participating in yesterday’s discussion, Awami League-led ruling coalition MPs called for the Supreme Judicial Council to remove the two judges for breaching the constitution and their oath of office.
They also demanded that parliament amend the constitution to revive its authority [in the 1972 constitution], to impeach apex court judges, scrapping the existing system of a Supreme Judicial Council, which was introduced during Ziaur Rahman’s rule.
Citing article 78 of the constitution, which deals with the privileges and immunities of parliament and its members, the lawmakers said it does not allow the court to raise any question about parliament proceedings. The two judges in question overstepped their jurisdiction by questioning the Speaker’s ruling, they alleged.
Several MPs, including AL’s Sheikh Fazlul Karim Selim and Sayeedul Haque, Jatiya Samajtantrik Dal’s Hasanul Haque Inu and Mayeen Uddin Khan Badal and Jatiya Party’s Mujibul Haque said if no action was taken against the controversial judges, the country will face a condition similar to that in Pakistan.
The Pakistan judiciary, with Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhury playing an over-zealous role in prosecuting politicians, has seen a prime minister fall and has pushed the temperature up in the case of another.
Ten lawmakers participated in the discussion that lasted over two hours.
Sheikh Selim initiated the discussion. The Speaker then gave the floor to State Minister for Law Quamrul Islam.
Citing the government appeal against the HC verdict, the state minister said the matter was sub judice, and so the MPs should keep it in mind while they speak.
Rejecting Quamrul’s argument, the Speaker said the HC verdict could not be sub judice, as parliament did not file any appeal against it. “It’s not a case like those filed for murder or property disputes. It is related to the constitution and in no way can it be sub judice,” he observed.
He, however, urged the MPs not to use aggressive language.
Relations between the legislature and the judiciary got strained after Justice Manik observed during a June 5 hearing that the Speaker had committed an offence tantamount to sedition by commenting in parliament on an HC order.
The judge also said the Speaker was ignorant of the apex court and the constitution.
Justice Manik’s remarks came in response to some observations made by Speaker Abdul Hamid in the House on May 29.
Hamid had told the House that courts were neutral and independent. However, it looked odd when they took quick decisions to resolve their own problems while people waited for years to get justice.
He had also said that if people were aggrieved at court verdicts, a day would come when they would stand against the courts. “Likewise, if the government becomes autocratic, people will resist it and there are numerous instances of it.”
Hours after Manik’s remarks against the Speaker, the ruling alliance MPs blasted the judge and accused him of violating the constitution by making “derogatory remarks” against the Speaker.
Finally, the Speaker on June 18 gave a ruling on the matter.
But the issue got back to the fore when Justice Foez and Justice Altaf came up with their verdict on the Speaker’s ruling.
Opening the unscheduled discussion yesterday, Sheikh Selim said a vested quarter had launched the attack on the Speaker. “It’s an attack on parliament and democracy. So it cannot be accepted.”
He said the two judges had passed the verdict out of the blue. The matter had already been settled peacefully through the Speaker’s ruling.
Senior AL lawmaker Tofail Ahmed said: “In the name of observations, the two judges gave a 38-page verdict, which surprised us. Those who gave the verdict just cannot do so.”
Tofail also questioned whether Justice Altaf was eligible to be a judge of the High Court as “he had not been a practising lawyer of the Supreme Court for 10 years in a row”.
He also blasted Justice Manik for what he described as his various irregularities and dual citizenship. “Justice Manik is also a British citizen. Mr Speaker, you will now find him in Britain,” Tofail said.
He said another judge named Hasan Feroz was also not eligible to be a High Court judge, as he had not fulfilled the requirement of practising in the top court for 10 years.
“Who is Justice Hasan Feroz? He is a son-in-law of Justice Manik’s brother,” Tofail said.
“If the Supreme Court does not take any action against Justice Manik, people will lose confidence in the judiciary,” he added.
Terming the Speaker’s ruling a legislative judgment, former railway minister Suranjit Sengupta said a Supreme Court judgment can be reviewed, but not a legislative judgment.
“If the Speaker’s ruling does not exist as per the court’s verdict, parliament does not exist either. If parliament does not exist, the judiciary too does not exist and neither do the judges,” he said.
“It is an unwise judgment and the judges did not apply their judicial minds to delivering it,” Suranjit added.
The veteran parliamentarian also condemned the judges who were part of martial law regimes. “There was no martial law where there was no link of Supreme Court judges. Even a sitting chief justice [Justice Abu Sadaat Mohammad Sayem] had become the chief martial law administrator.”
Citing the introduction of the Supreme Judicial Council, he said after the assassination of Bangabandhu, the judiciary in league with the junta usurped the authority to investigate allegations of misconduct against judges.
Workers Party chief Rashed Khan Menon urged the House to draw contempt of parliament proceedings against Justice Foez and Justice Altaf.
“I am requesting the House to send the matter to the Supreme Judicial Council for action against the two judges,” he said.
AL MP Sheikh Fazle Noor Taposh opposed discussing the verdict in parliament, saying it was sub judice.
At the end of the discussion, Speaker Abdul Hamid said he would let the House know his decision later. “I hope that everybody will be able to live in their respective position with due dignity and rights,” Hamid said.

Courtesy of The Daily Star

Related News

Two entire families lost to a road accident in Pirojpur

News Desk : dhakamirror.com At least eight people from two families, including four children, died after a private car plunged into a roadside canal in Pirojpur early today. The deceased are Shawon, 32, his wife Amina, 25, their two children Sahadat, 7, and Abdullah, 3, from Bhaijhora village of Pirojpur’s Nazirpur upazila and Motaleb Sheikh, ... Read more

Italian embassy to resolve 20,000 visa applications by December: Foreign adviser

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Foreign Affairs Adviser Md Touhid Hossain on Tuesday said that the Italian Embassy in Dhaka will clear 20,000 visa applications by December as many visa applications had been pending for a long time. “Twenty thousand visa cases have been cleared from Rome. [However] Progress in issuing those visas is very slow. ... Read more

Prof Mobasser Monem appointed as new PSC Chairman

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The government has appointed Dr Mobasser Monem, a Professor of Governance and Public Management at the University of Dhaka, as the new Chairman of the Bangladesh Public Service Commission (BPSC). Along with Professor Monem, four others have been appointed as members of the BPSC. The four members are– Md Suzayet Ullah, ... Read more

Govt urges IOM to evacuate Bangladeshis

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Dhaka has requested the International Organisation for Migration to arrange chartered flights to bring back Bangladeshis willing to leave Lebanon amid airstrikes by Israel on the West Asian country. ‘We have requested the IOM to arrange flights to evacuate Bangladeshis willing to leave Lebanon. But Beirut’s airport is currently unsafe for ... Read more

Flood puts hundreds at risk of starvation

Emran Hossain The ongoing flash flooding puts hundreds of farmer families at immediate risk of starvation in Sherpur district, washing away the rice they stored from the previous harvest and also destroying the standing paddy fields. The divisional office of the Department of Agricultural Extension estimated that the flood affected 97,000 hectares of standing aman ... Read more

Price hikes strain people

Moinul Haque The soaring prices of essential commodities, including rice, vegetables, eggs and broiler chicken, put increasing pressure on the low-income people, pushing them further to the wall. Market analysts have expressed concerns over the unusual spiralling of prices of the essentials, criticising the interim government for its failure to take timely action to protect ... Read more

Four days Durga Puja holiday starting from Thursday

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Bangladesh’s interim government has announced an additional public holiday on Thursday, October 10, for Durga Puja, the largest religious celebration of the Hindu community in Bangladesh, says a press release. During a press conference held on Wednesday at the Dhakeshwari Temple in Dhaka, Mahfuj Alam, special assistant to chief adviser, made ... Read more

Tiger population in Sundarbans rises to 125

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The number of Royal Bengal tigers in Bangladesh’s Sundarbans has increased to 125. The Ministry of Forests has published the results of the third phase of the tiger census. The survey was conducted between June 2023 and March 2024 to observe the population of the national animal of Bangladesh. Environment, forest ... Read more

Environment ministry asks BRTA to remove unfit vehicles from streets

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The environment, forest and climate change ministry on Sunday sent a letter to the Bangladesh Road Transport Authority requesting removal of buses, minibuses, trucks and covered vans exceeded their economic life from roads in an effort to reduce air pollution. The ministry, in a press release, also urged the authority to ... Read more

HSC results to be published on October 15

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The results of the Higher Secondary Certificate (HSC) and equivalent examinations of this year will be published on October 15. Dhaka Education Board Chairman and head of the Inter-Education Board Coordination Committee Prof Tapan Kumar Sarkar confirmed this information on Monday (October 7). The results will be published around 11:00am, Prof ... Read more

Worst-affected people get least aid: CPD

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The worst-affected people received the least relief assistance in the flash flooding that swept parts of Bangladesh in August affecting over 5.6 million people, revealed a Centre for Policy Dialogue analysis. The analysis, released on Sunday, estimates the overall loss and damage suffered by 11 districts in the flood at minimum ... Read more

47th BCS circular to be released in due time

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Bangladesh Public Service Commission (PSC) is preparing to release the circular for the 47th Bangladesh Civil Service (BCS) examination in due time. They are now discussing the issue with the public administration ministry. According to the cadre section of the BPSC, the number of vacancies are yet to be finalised, but ... Read more

Flood causes damage worth Tk 14,421 crore in eastern Bangladesh: CPD

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The recent floods in eastern Bangladesh caused damage estimated at Tk 14,421.46 crore, which is around $1.20 billion, according to a study by the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD). The findings were presented at a media briefing titled “Recent Flood Damage and Rehabilitation Process in Eastern Region: CPD’s Analysis” at the ... Read more

Malaysia to accept 18,000 workers who missed deadline

Says Asif Nazrul News Desk : dhakamirror.com Malaysia has agreed to receive 18,000 Bangladeshi workers who previously missed a deadline to enter the country, said Dr Asif Nazrul, adviser to the Ministry of Expatriates’ Welfare and Overseas Employment. “Now, the Ministry of Expatriates’ Welfare of Bangladesh will work with our Malaysian counterparts to establish a ... Read more

3 killed as gas cylinder blasts at restaurant in Keraniganj

News Desk : dhakamirror.com At least three restaurant workers were killed and several others injured in a gas cylinder blast on Saturday evening at ‘Ghorowa Hotel and Restaurant’ at Ramer Kanda in Keraniganj in Dhaka. Three other shops were also burnt in the incident as the fire broke out from the restaurant. The victims are ... Read more

Ex-president Badruddoza Chowdhury dies at 93

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Former president Professor AQM Badruddoza Chowdhury, popularly known as B Chowdhury, passed away in the early hours of Saturday (5 October). He was 93. The former president breathed his last at the Medical College for Women in Uttara at 3:10am, Jahangir Alam, press secretary of the former president, said in a ... Read more

Two students drown in Mirsarai waterfall

News Desk : dhakamirror.com The bodies of two young tourists were recovered from the deep well of Rupashi Waterfall in Chattogram’s Mirsarai yesterday (4 October), hours after they were reported missing. The deceased were identified as Musfiqur Rahman, 21, and Mahbub Rahman Mustakim, 21, both residents of Narayanganj. “A search and rescue team from the ... Read more

Railway to operate special passenger trains on Dhaka-Cox’s Bazar route during Durga Puja holidays

News Desk : dhakamirror.com In anticipation of increased demand during the Durga Puja and weekly holidays, the Bangladesh Railway has decided to operate seven additional special passenger trains on the Dhaka-Cox’s Bazar route. These trains will run from 10 October to 13 October, supplementing the two regular trains already operating on the route. The director ... Read more

Bangladeshi expat wins Tk 65 cr in lottery in UAE Big Ticket draw

News Desk : dhakamirror.com Bangladeshi expat Abul Monsur, hailing from Chattogram, has won Dh20 million, or over Tk65 crore, grand prize with the latest Big Ticket draw in the United Arab Emirates. Abul Monsur Abdul Sabur, a 50-year-old based in Abu Dhabi, has been buying the raffle draws’ entries since 2007. In its latest edition, ... Read more

Motorcycle sales tumble to seven-year low

Mahfuz Ullah Babu Rising costs, consumers’ weakening purchasing capacity, and adverse policy treatments blamed The hope of manufacturers for a scaled-up motorcycle market – to reach a million units a year by 2027 – now seems to be fading away. The economic slowdown, coupled with a sharp rise in costs and selling prices, has instead ... Read more