Saturday, October 12, 2024

US retailers see ‘big risk’ in joining Bangladesh RMG accord

The US retail companies are sharply opposed to joining the international plan to improve safety conditions at garment factories in Bangladesh as their European counterparts and consumer and labour groups dismiss the companies’ concerns about legal liability, reports the New York Times.
A few shareholders at Gap’s annual meeting this week questioned the company’s refusal to sign on to a plan that commits retailers to help finance safety upgrades in Bangladesh, where 1,127 workers died when the Rana Plaza factory building collapsed on April 24.
‘In the United States, there’s maybe a bigger legal risk than there is in Europe,’ Gap chief executive Glenn Murphy responded. ‘If we were to sign onto something that had unlimited legal liability and risk, I think our shareholders should care about that.’
Whether the new accord would subject retailers to substantial legal risks has been debated since nearly three dozen European retailers embraced the plan last week while almost all major American companies shunned it. The plan, called the Accord on Factory and Building Safety in Bangladesh, was forged by retailers, union leaders and government officials overseas.
Labour advocacy groups and other supporters of the plan pilloried the responses by Gap, Walmart and other American retailers that have decided to rely on their own inspection systems rather than join the plan.
Johan Lubbe, a legal adviser to the National Retail Federation, asserts that the Americans’ worries about litigation are legitimate. ‘The liability issue is of great concern, at least on this side of the Atlantic,’ Lubbe said. ‘For US corporations, there is a fear that someone will try to impose liability and responsibility if something goes awry in the global supply chain.’
For example, if a Bangladesh factory burns and workers die, the victims’ families, represented by zealous American lawyers, might seize on the legal commitments in the accord to file lawsuits in the United States against retailers that bought apparel from the factory.
John C Coffee Jr, a professor of corporate law at Columbia University, said American companies generally faced a higher risk of litigation than overseas competitors, largely because the court systems differ significantly. Unlike the system in the United States, courts in Europe generally prohibit class-action lawsuits, do not allow contingency fees for lawyers who win cases and require losing parties to pay legal fees for both sides. Those policies often discourage lawyers and plaintiffs from filing lawsuits.
But Professor Coffee also cited a Supreme Court decision last month that could greatly reduce the ability of overseas factory workers and their families to file lawsuits in United States courts.
‘It may be that those retailers who worry about legal liability are pointing to an outdated sense of what liability is for actions taken abroad,’ Professor Coffee said. He added that if an accident occurred abroad — for instance, at a factory in Bangladesh — ‘there is an increasing doubt that the American retailer could be sued in the United States,’ because the Supreme Court ruling, Kiobel v Royal Dutch Petroleum, went far to curb such lawsuits under the Alien Tort Claims Act.
Long before the Bangladesh safety plan was developed, overseas workers had sued American retailers over low wages, 12-hour shifts and the use of guard dogs and barbed wire fences, said
Scott Nova, executive director of the Worker Rights Consortium, a university-backed factory monitoring group. In 2003, Gap, Nordstrom, Target, Walmart and 20 other retailers settled a lawsuit for $20 million on behalf of 30,000 garment workers on the Pacific island of Saipan who alleged those abuses.
Lubbe cited a more recent lawsuit as evidence that American retailers still faced risks. Last year, the University of Wisconsin sued Adidas, demanding that it pay $1.8 million in severance benefits to former workers at an Indonesian factory it used. The factory’s owner had failed to comply with an order to pay those benefits to 2,800 workers who lost their jobs.
Nova said the University of Wisconsin lawsuit was based on a licensing agreement with more specific obligations than the Bangladesh accord. Adidas had pledged to comply with a labour code of conduct that said it must ‘ensure that all manufacturers comply’ with the code and ‘provide legally mandated benefits,’ such as severance benefits.
Under the international agreement, a great number of Bangladesh’s more than 5,000 apparel factories could be affected. Some workplace experts estimate that fixing safety problems could cost at least $500,000 on average per factory, meaning that the countrywide price tag could easily exceed $1 billion over several years. Some note, however, that the expense would be just a fraction of the $18 billion worth of apparel exported annually by Bangladesh, the second-largest garment exporter after China.
Gap’s spokesman, Bill Chandler, said the accord contained numerous provisions that worried American retailers. He said the plan’s binding, contractual nature could impose large legal obligations that were hard to estimate because of the plan’s ambiguities.
For instance, it does not detail how much the Bangladeshi apparel manufacturer should pay toward needed safety upgrades — perhaps factories lack a fire escape — and how much the Western companies that use those factories should pay. Another ambiguity is how costs for safety improvements will be apportioned among the several Western companies that buy garments from a given factory in Bangladesh.
‘The language is vague and unclear and thus there can be too much legal liability for our company in Bangladesh,’ Chandler said. Such statements cause some supporters of the plan to assert that American retailers’ real objection is the price of financing safety improvements.
Paul Lister, director of legal services at Associated British Foods, the parent of Primark, a retailer that has signed the Bangladesh accord, acknowledged that the plan has ambiguities. He said the signatories planned to work with government and labour officials over the next 45 days to decide on the details.
‘It’s not a perfect document,’ Lister said. ‘We’ll deal with the imperfections in the document, and we have to deal urgently with the underlying issue — the moral and ethical issues of fire safety and building integrity in Bangladesh.’
Sounding far different from American retailers, Anna Gedda, manager for social sustainability at H&M, the Swedish company that is the biggest buyer of apparel from Bangladesh, voiced little concern about legal liability.
‘The fact that it was a legally binding accord was not a big issue,’ she said. ‘I know it is for American brands but it isn’t for us.’ The accord contains a clause that calls for settling disputes through independent arbitrators in an effort to keep disputes out of court.
‘This whole fear of lawsuits is a straw man,’ said Philip J Jennings, general secretary of Uni Global Union, a worldwide federation of 20 million retail and service workers, who has negotiated with various retailers to develop the plan and persuaded them to join it. ‘If these American retailers get 20 lawyers in a room, they start hyperventilating about lawsuits and they’ll have a communal anxiety attack.’
Matthew Shay, president of the National Retail Federation, gave another reason for opposing the Bangladesh plan, saying it ‘seeks to advance a narrow agenda driven by special interests,’ a reference to the labour unions that helped shape the plan and then pressed retailers to sign on.
Jyrki Raina, general secretary of IndustriALL, a union federation with 50 million members from 140 countries, said that European retailers were receptive because they often deal with and negotiate with labour unions.
In rejecting the accord, Walmart outlined its own proposals that it said would meet or exceed the accord’s goals. The company, the world’s largest retailer, predicted quicker results, saying it would inspect all of the 279 factories it uses in Bangladesh over the next six months.
While Walmart, voicing concern about potential liability, said the plan ‘introduces requirements, including governance and dispute resolution mechanisms, on supply chain matters that are appropriately left to retailers, suppliers and government.’
Representative Sander Levin of Michigan, the senior Democrat on the House Ways and Means Committee who has urged the Obama administration to do more to improve factory safety in Bangladesh, criticised Walart’s approach. ‘It’s been left up to the retailers, suppliers and government all these years, and that hasn’t worked,’ he said.

-With New Age input

Related News

Luxury car sales slow to a near-stop

Market players blame economic and political uncertainty Jagaran Chakma Sales of luxury sedans and sport utility vehicles (SUVs) have been almost nil since July this year as customers have reined in spending amid the ongoing economic downturn and sudden political changeover in Bangladesh. According to various market insiders, sales have fallen by about 95 percent ... Read more

realme 12: The Speed Dominator launched

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com realme has unveiled its latest handset, the realme 12, in Bangladesh featuring SUPERVOOC charging, fluid performance and photographic prowess. This new device sets unprecedented standards with the ‘Born for Speed’ philosophy in the mid-range segment, reads a press release. At the core of the realme 12 is the Qualcomm Snapdragon chipset, ... Read more

TECNO mobile Bangladesh wins best retailer award 2024

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com TECNO Mobile Bangladesh has been awarded the title of the best retailer of mobile handsets at the prestigious Bangladesh retail congress . This honour is a testament to our unwavering focus on enhancing consumer satisfaction and convenience. We believe that our consumers are at the heart of our success and are ... Read more

Mastercard hold technology conference 2024

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Mastercard recently organised the “Mastercard Tech Conference Q4, 2024” at a city hotel in Dhaka, Bangladesh, with participants from various banks and financial institutions. Zakia Sultana and Sohail Alim, Directors at Mastercard, Bangladesh, inaugurated the session. Munish Jairath, Director of Technology Account Management, Vageesh Raghavendra, Manager of Technology Account Management, and ... Read more

Stellar performers in Bangladesh travel, tourism and hospitality are honoured

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com The recognition programme, first of its kind in the country, was organised by the travel and tourism publication the Bangladesh Monitor. The programme is supported by Prime Bank PLC, a private-sector financial institution whose commitment to the industry’s growth is unwavering. Online travel agency BuyTickets, travel technology provider Sabre, and tea ... Read more

Businesses urge steps on law and order

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Business leaders on Saturday sought better business climate in the country and said that issues like law and order situation, rising interest rates and other macroeconomic challenges must be addressed as these factors have impacted the economy negatively. Speaking at a seminar titled ‘Current state of the economy and outlook of ... Read more

Walton launches solar hybrid IPS

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Walton Digi-Tech Industries Limited, a sister concern of Walton Group, recently launched solar hybrid Instant Power Supply (IPS) units, which are environment friendly, renewable and affordable as well. The price caps of these IPS units start from a minimum of Tk 79,500 and maximum Tk 465,000, depending on the inverter and ... Read more

Walton to attend in Canton Fair for the fourth time

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Global electronics brand Walton is set to attend the ‘China Import and Export Fair’, widely known as the Canton Fair, for the fourth time. This prestigious event, recognized as one of the largest trade shows in the world, will see Walton showcase its latest AI-powered electronics and electrical products. The 136th ... Read more

First drone manufacturing factory to be set up in country

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Bangladeshi company Sky Bees Limited is set to invest US$ 45.95 million to establish an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV, commonly known as drone) manufacturing industry in the BEPZA Economic Zone (BEPZA EZ). This will be the first factory to manufacture drones in the zones under BEPZA, creating employment opportunities for 55 ... Read more

OPPO A3 now available in Bangladesh

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com In a world where smartphones face constant challenges, OPPO is setting a new benchmark for durability with the launch of the OPPO A3 Series in Bangladesh. Designed as the ultimate durability champion, the OPPO A3 showcases OPPO’s commitment to enduring the rigours of daily life. Built with a robust structure to ... Read more

NBR scraps black money whitening scheme

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com The National Board of Revenue has cancelled the provision to whiten black money without scrutiny by paying a 15 percent tax. The tax administration issued a notification in this regard today. The development comes a few days after the interim government said it had decided to scrap the provision. The exemption ... Read more

BRAC Bank introduces VISA Platinum Flexi Card

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com BRAC Bank has introduced a new ‘VISA Platinum Flexi Credit Card’, exclusively designed for the youth and young professionals aspiring to elevate their lifestyle. The new credit card comes with a wide range of lifestyle, travel, hotel stay, and dine-in benefits for cardholders at a competitive annual fee, according to a ... Read more

Biswas Imports: Leading the way in Bangladesh’s car market

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Biswas Imports has become a standout in Bangladesh’s car industry since starting as a Facebook page in 2015 by Mr Musa Biswas. The name “Biswas” means “Trust” in Bengali, reflecting their commitment to integrity and reliability. Specialising in importing and selling high-quality new and reconditioned cars from Japan, Europe, and the ... Read more

Bangladesh set to launch direct flights with Switzerland

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Bangladesh is set to launch direct flights with Switzerland with at least 14 flights operating between the countries per week. The Government of Bangladesh and the Swiss Federal Council in Bern inked an agreement to this end on 4 June, marking significant progress in expanding the country’s air travel network, reads ... Read more

Emirates eliminates online payment limit for flights in BDT

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Emirates has made online payment more convenient for customers purchasing tickets in Bangladesh. Now, customers can use locally issued debit and credit cards to complete payment transactions online for flight tickets and enjoy the convenience of unlimited transactions in BDT. Customers can enjoy the ease of paying for tickets on emirates.com, ... Read more

Aziz Khan next chair of Unicef Int’l Council

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Unicef has announced Muhammed Aziz Khan as the incoming chair of the Unicef International Council, succeeding the inaugural chair, Maria Ahlstrom-Bondestam. He will assume the position in November this year, a press release issued by Unicef said yesterday. The Unicef International Council is a unique community of approximately 150 private philanthropists ... Read more

NJ Diamonds brings vibrant luxury jewelry to Bangladesh

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com NJ Diamonds, a new luxury jewelry brand, has officially launched in the capital at Banani road 11. The event was a glittering affair, attended by top influencers and industry elites, marking a significant milestone for the Bangladesh jewelry market. NJ Diamonds, founded by Noorjahan Abdullah & Labiba Abdullah, are set to ... Read more

NCC Bank celebrates 31 years of operations

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com NCC Bank celebrated its 31 years of operations at the bank’s head office in Dhaka on Friday. Md Abul Bashar, chairman of the bank, inaugurated the 31st anniversary programme, said a press release. NCC Bank started its journey on May 17, 1993. “During the 31 year-long-journey, the bank played a remarkable ... Read more

21 winners receive gifts from Nagad’s mega campaign

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com A total of 21 winners have received different gifts by taking part in the country’s biggest transactions campaign – initiated by Nagad, a popular mobile financial service provider. Recently, Nagad’s Senior Executive Vice-President and Chief Marketing Officer Sadat Adnan Ahmad and Executive Vice-President and Deputy Chief Marketing Officer Muhammad Solaiman handed ... Read more

Hatil Chairman Selim H Rahman honoured with CIP award

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Selim H Rahman, the esteemed Chairman and Managing Director of HATIL, a leading name in the furniture industry, was conferred with the prestigious Commercially Important Person (CIP) award for his pioneering contributions to the export of the furniture sector. The ceremony held at the Radisson Blu Water Garden Hotel, Dhaka, on ... Read more