Friday, December 27, 2024

Doubt over benefits of FTA with India

Analysts yesterday expressed doubt over a World Bank idea that a free trade agreement (FTA) with India will boost Bangladesh’s exports to the neighbour.
Instead of an FTA, they stressed increasing trade facilitation, market access, regional connectivity and investment to raise Bangladesh’s exports to India.
They also put emphasis on the removal of non-tariff barriers (NTBs).
Sanjay Kathuria, lead economist of the WB in Bangladesh, shared the suggestion of the lender at a dialogue, forecasting that an FTA will raise Bangladesh’s exports by up to 133 percent to India.
It will also open up production-sharing possibilities in textiles and clothing, iron and steel as well as electrical machinery and equipment making because of trade complementarities between the two countries, according to a WB study.
“This is just the tip of the iceberg. Trade complementarities will grow with time,” said Kathuria, presenting the study — Bangladesh-India Trade Relationship: New Opportunities, New Challenges — at the dialogue.
Selim Raihan, associate professor of economics at the University of Dhaka, co-authored the study.
The Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) in collaboration with the WB organised the event at BRAC Centre Inn in Dhaka, where Prime Minister’s Foreign Affairs Adviser Gowher Rizvi and Commerce Secretary Md Ghulam Hussain also spoke.
CPD Distinguished Fellow Debapriya Bhattacharya chaired the session.
Kathuria said Bangladesh and India’s relationship is rich but it remains below its potential.
To realise the prospect both the countries will have to further liberalise trade, cut tariffs, reduce non-tariff barriers and take steps to facilitate more trade, he said.
“The bilateral FTA will be a building block towards regional cooperation,” said the WB economist, arguing that Bangladesh will hardly achieve 8 percent growth without significant cooperation with neighbours –India, Nepal and Bhutan.
“A full FTA plus improved connectivity would result in a much higher export growth,” said Kathuria.
Commerce Secretary Ghulam Hussain said, apart from the benefit of the bilateral FTA, impact on employment, industry, poverty and revenue should be taken into account.
“I am not convinced that we should go for an FTA with India,” Hussain said, citing that Bangladesh received such proposals earlier, but the conclusion was negative.
He said Bangladesh gets duty-free access to India excluding 25 product lines. Trade facilitation and removal of NTBs will boost bilateral trade further, he said.
Instead of an FTA, Bangladesh should work on trade facilitation issues, said CPD Senior Research Fellow Khondaker Golam Moazzem.
He said increased market access and better regional connectivity will raise Bangladesh’s exports.
Mostafa Abid Khan of Bangladesh Tariff Commission also questioned the prediction of the WB on Bangladesh-India FTA.
In 2004, a similar WB study did not find any benefit from such an FTA between the two countries, he said.
Khan said Bangladesh should go for a comprehensive agreement that would incorporate connectivity, investment, trade facilitation and other aspects.
“The study has raised expectations and concerns, said Osman Faruk, an adviser to the chairperson of opposition BNP.
He said India’s actual exports to Bangladesh are much higher because of a huge informal trade.
“India has to take proactive measures to reduce NTBs to boost bilateral trade,” said Faruq, also a former WB economist and a former minister.
On connectivity with India, he suggested considering the matter more from regional perspective, encompassing Nepal, Bhutan, Myanmar and China.
He said providing transit to India may erode comparative advantages of Bangladesh’s garment products in northeast Indian states.
Bangladesh Foreign Trade Institute’s Chief Executive Mozibur Rahman expressed doubt over the predicted export growth for the FTA. “We have to be very cautious in forecasting the potential. Growth cannot be linear and horizontal type,” he said.
Citing a study of the Asian Development Bank, he said gains would be higher for Nepal and Bhutan for regional connectivity.
He said gains for India will be $3.billion for using Bangladesh’s ports, railway and roads for transporting goods to its northeast region.
Bangladesh will gain only $200-300 million, said Rahman, citing an estimate.
Referring to India’s FTA with Sri Lanka, former ambassador Ashfaqur Rahman said Sri Lanka is not happy with the trade deal.
Sohel Ahmed Chowdhury, a former commerce secretary, cited a lack of investment from the Indian side for trade facilitation with Bangladesh. Bangladesh established a land port in Banglabandha in 2004, but India did nothing, he said.
Former ambassador Farooq Sobhan said the issue of trade facilitation needs to addressed.
Kathuria, in reply, said the WB study in 2004 considered that garments would not be competitive.
He said the FTA will increase formal trade and enhance revenue. The increased trade will also impact prices and thus contribute to poverty reduction, he said.
PM’s Foreign Affairs Adviser Gowher Rizvi said further examination is necessary before signing an FTA with India.
Rizvi said Indian investors are showing interest to invest here. “But, we need a transparent policy to attract investment.”
He said the both sides should at first find all the NTBs between them.
CPD Distinguished Fellow Debapriya Bhattachariya said Bangladesh should focus on sub-regional cooperation.
Summing up the discussion, he said instead of an FTA, a comprehensive framework agreement that incorporates issues such as trade facilitation, investments, trade in services, and infrastructure development, may be considered.

-With The Daily Star input

Related News

Walton receives orders amounting Tk 350 crore at ATS Expo

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Walton received orders worth around Tk 350 crore from various local and foreign companies at the “Advanced Technology Solution-ATS Expo 2024”, the country’s sole industrial expo organised by tech-giant Walton. SM Mahbubul Alam, managing director of Walton Hi-Tech Industries, provided the disclosure at the event’s closing ceremony. The three-day expo ended ... Read more

Big price drop on Walton desktops, extra 10% off for online orders

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Walton Digi-Tech Industries Limited, the leading technology product manufacturing and marketing company in Bangladesh, has come up with a huge price drop on its desktop computers. This attractive price drop is applicable on the company’s AMD Ryzen™ processor-powered Avian series desktops. Under this, customers are enjoying a minimum price drop of ... Read more

bKash wins Mastercard Excellence Awards

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com bKash, the largest mobile financial service (MFS) provider in Bangladesh, recently won an award at the “Mastercard Excellence Awards” in recognition of its exceptional contributions to advancing financial inclusion and fostering a robust digital economy. The MFS provider was awarded by the US-based digital payment provider in the digital business category ... Read more

Dhaka resident buys Marcel fridge, wins car

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Anisur Rahman, a resident of Uttarkhan, Dhaka, became the first lucky winner of a brand-new car under Marcel’s Digital Campaign Season-21, after purchasing a Marcel refrigerator. This campaign offers customers a chance to win a free car or assured gifts with the purchase of Marcel refrigerators, air conditioners, washing machines, and ... Read more

Banglalink teams up with Vivo to provide special data deals for youth

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Banglalink, the country’s innovative digital operator, has partnered with vivo to launch a data offer specifically designed for tech-savvy youth. This collaboration aims to provide more convenient access to various digital services and exclusive content. Aligned with the ‘Youth’s Choice Smartphone’ proposition, Banglalink is offering 18GB of free data with the ... Read more

Emirates adjudged Best Airline in the World at the ULTRAs 2024 Awards

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Emirates has once again been honored with the title of ‘Best Airline in the World’ at the esteemed ULTRAs 2024 Awards. Recognized by thousands of travelers worldwide, the airline stood out for its outstanding products, innovative services, and exceptional value-for-money experiences. Thierry Aucoc, Emirates Senior Vice President Commercial Operations in Europe ... Read more

Remittance rises in Oct, SOBs log larger share

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Remittance inflow to Bangladesh increased by more than 21 per cent in October compared with that in the same month in the past year, as expatriates favoured official channels, mainly state-owned banks, following a significant political shift in the country on August 5. Bangladesh Bank data showed that remittance inflows reached ... Read more

Oppo celebrates tenth anniversary in Bangladesh with O Fans festival

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Emphasising celebration and appreciation, OPPO, a leading global technology brand, is excited to announce its SUPER OFFER as part of the ‘O Fans Festival’ to celebrate its 10th anniversary in Bangladesh. The festival theme, “SUPER OFFER,” highlights unforgettable experiences for its dedicated fans through exclusive prizes and substantial super discounts on ... Read more

Bangladesh Travel and Tourism Council launched

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com A new think tank, Bangladesh Travel and Tourism Council (BTTC), has started its journey in a bid to create a network of professionals and businesses to foster collaboration and knowledge exchange in the local travel, tourism and hospitality sector. The council held its first meeting at a hotel in the capital ... Read more

Ethiopian airlines set to touch Dhaka’s runway

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Ethiopian Airlines, the largest airline in Africa and part of the Star Alliance, will begin operations in Bangladesh next Sunday with its first flight on the new Addis Ababa-Dhaka route. The airline will provide five direct flights each week, giving Bangladeshi travelers access to over 155 global destinations, including major cities ... Read more

Unilever’s 15th edition of BizMaestros launches Nov 3

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com The 15th edition of BizMaestros-UFLP, the flagship business competition of Unilever Bangladesh, embodying the “Thrill of Real Business”, is all set to begin on November 3. As a leading player in the FMCG sector, Unilever Bangladesh has been at the forefront of skill development initiatives for over six decades, establishing BizMaestros ... Read more

Banglalink introduces affordable 4G Phone in partnership with Symphony

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Banglalink and Symphony have joined forces to launch the “My First 4G Phone” campaign to make 4G technology more accessible and affordable. Through this campaign, they seek to bridge the digital divide by offering high-quality 4G phones at an unbeatable price, empowering more people to benefit from fast, reliable internet connectivity.The ... Read more

Bashundhara Toiletries introduces “Alora 2in1” Hair & Body Wash: first ever in Bangladesh

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Bashundhara Toiletries announced the launch of “Alora 2-in-1” Hair and Body Wash, an innovative product designed to simplify your daily care routine. As Bangladesh’s first 2-in-1 solution for both hair and skin, Alora offers a unique blend of premium ingredients that cleanse, nourish, and revitalize. “Alora 2-in-1” is formulated with two ... Read more

350cc Royal Enfield set for Bangladesh launch on October 21

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Ifad Motors, the manufacturer and sole distributor of Royal Enfield motorcycles in Bangladesh, is gearing up to launch the iconic motorcycle brand in the country on Monday (21 October). Four models will be introduced: Bullet, Meteor, Hunter, and Classic and the bikers will have 12 different colour options at competitive prices ... Read more

Luxury car sales slow to a near-stop

Market players blame economic and political uncertainty Jagaran Chakma Sales of luxury sedans and sport utility vehicles (SUVs) have been almost nil since July this year as customers have reined in spending amid the ongoing economic downturn and sudden political changeover in Bangladesh. According to various market insiders, sales have fallen by about 95 percent ... Read more

realme 12: The Speed Dominator launched

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com realme has unveiled its latest handset, the realme 12, in Bangladesh featuring SUPERVOOC charging, fluid performance and photographic prowess. This new device sets unprecedented standards with the ‘Born for Speed’ philosophy in the mid-range segment, reads a press release. At the core of the realme 12 is the Qualcomm Snapdragon chipset, ... Read more

TECNO mobile Bangladesh wins best retailer award 2024

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com TECNO Mobile Bangladesh has been awarded the title of the best retailer of mobile handsets at the prestigious Bangladesh retail congress . This honour is a testament to our unwavering focus on enhancing consumer satisfaction and convenience. We believe that our consumers are at the heart of our success and are ... Read more

Mastercard hold technology conference 2024

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Mastercard recently organised the “Mastercard Tech Conference Q4, 2024” at a city hotel in Dhaka, Bangladesh, with participants from various banks and financial institutions. Zakia Sultana and Sohail Alim, Directors at Mastercard, Bangladesh, inaugurated the session. Munish Jairath, Director of Technology Account Management, Vageesh Raghavendra, Manager of Technology Account Management, and ... Read more

Stellar performers in Bangladesh travel, tourism and hospitality are honoured

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com The recognition programme, first of its kind in the country, was organised by the travel and tourism publication the Bangladesh Monitor. The programme is supported by Prime Bank PLC, a private-sector financial institution whose commitment to the industry’s growth is unwavering. Online travel agency BuyTickets, travel technology provider Sabre, and tea ... Read more

Businesses urge steps on law and order

Business Desk : dhakamirror.com Business leaders on Saturday sought better business climate in the country and said that issues like law and order situation, rising interest rates and other macroeconomic challenges must be addressed as these factors have impacted the economy negatively. Speaking at a seminar titled ‘Current state of the economy and outlook of ... Read more